PinnyWise /

Rate Pins /

Pin List

@pinnywise

All Pins

Sorted by: Chronological Reverse-Chron Ranking

Rank is determined by community votes using the Rating Tool. The rating tool was introduced early 2019 and rankings reflect 3773 total community votes, so far. To improve accuracy of the ratings, please consider voting!

Creation of Gabe
Set: Creation of Gabe
This pin set was sold for $150 online - it sold out in 85 seconds. It is a Limited Edition of 150. Each set is hand signed and numbered by Mike and Jerry. Its huge, and not exactly a pin you will see hanging on a lanyard (unless it belongs to Flava Flav).
DLC Kickstarter
Set: DLC Kickstarter 2013
Only 300 were made, before Pinny Arcade was very popular, available only to those who backed PAs 2013 Kickstarter at the $150 level and up. If you are lucky enough to find one - keep it secret, keep it safe! This is by far the most rare Pinny Arcade pin, and likely to retain that title forever.
Aus Kemper
Set: Aus Core 2013
Available for purchase at the Pax Aus 2013 merch booth. This was the first Aus PAX, and also the first year of Pinny Arcade. Not many of these sets were made, and they remain as some of the most sought after pins.
Handheld Gabe
Set: East Core 2013
Available for purchase at the Pax East 2013 merch booth.
East Kemper
Set: East Core 2013
Available for purchase at the Pax East 2013 merch booth.
Star Trek Timelines
Set: East Partners 2015
Available from Disruptor Beam at booth 6068 by completing the game demo and joining the Bridge Crew.
PAX Prime 10th Year
Set: Merch Exclusive 2014
Limited Edition PAX Anniversary Pin. Similar to the PAX East pin, this will be available for sale in limited quantities (until sold out) at the merch booth.
Kitty Kemper
Set: Prime Core 2013
Available for purchase at the Pax Prime 2013 merch booth.
DSB Kemper
Set: Limited 2017
Rare catch from 2017 Double Secret Blind boxes from the PA online store.
Hanna
Set: Hanna 2013
Hanna was the first official Limited Edition pin - only 1,000 were made and they sold out online in Oct 2013 in less than 15 minutes. Many people were able to buy two pins, so you may see them available for trade, but its going to cost you. This pin celebrates the Daughters of Eyrewood comic series.
Aus Gabe
Set: Aus Core 2013
Available for purchase at the Pax Aus 2013 merch booth. This was the first Aus PAX, and also the first year of Pinny Arcade. Not many of these sets were made, and they remain as some of the most sought after pins. Probably the rarest Gabe and Tycho character pins.
Robert Khoo
Set: Staff 2014
Part of the 2014 Staff Pins set, revealed at Pax Prime 2014. Get this by trading with Khoo anytime.
Blind Merch
Set: Limited 2015
Available exclusivly in random double blind pin boxes from the PA online store, summer 2015. Only 500 of these were printed, and they were distributed randomly. After the DLC pin, this is the next rarest (and likely next-most sought after) pinny arcade pin.
PAX East 2017 LE
Set: Limited 2017
Available ONLY at both Merch booth. Supply with be rationed out over 3 days.
80s Gabe
Set: Prime Core 2014
Part of the Prime 2014 Core set. Available for purchase at the merch booth, South Lobby of the main Expo Hall.
PAX Aus LE 2018
Set: Aus 2018 Limited
ONLY available at the PAX Merch Lite Booth located in the Exhibition Centre Concourse Foyer.
D&D
Set: East Partners 2014
The D&D 40th Anniversary pin was given out to attendees of the Acquisitions Inc panel at East 2014.
Kemper Wreath
Set: Christmas 2016
Available by purchasing from the PA online store, Winter 2016.
Scuba Kemper
Set: Aus Core 2015
Part of the Pax Aus 2015 core set. Only available from the merch booth at Pax Aus 2015.
Overwatch Gold
Set: East Partners 2015
Awarded by Blizzard by winning their Play of the Game during an Overwatch match.
VR Kemper
Set: West Core 2016
Available for purchase from the PAX West (does Prime = West now? Ugh..) merch booth.
PAX Aus LE 2017
Set: Aus 2017 Limited
Available at Pax Aus 2017.
Automata Kickstarter 1
Set: Limited Ed 2015
Available by supporting the Summer 2015 Automata Kickstarter project at the $150 level. These kickstarter pins are likely to be very limited, and highly collectible.
Thornwatch Kickstarter
Set: Limited Ed 2016
Exclusivly available during the 2016 Thornwatch board game kickstarter campaign, pledging $128 or more. Judging from the contributions, less than a thousand were produced, and will never be made available again.
New Year 2019
Set: LE 2019
Limited Edition pin produced and sold online for New Year 2019. 450 total produced.
PAX Aus 10th Year
Set: Merch Exclusive 2014
Limited Edition PAX Anniversary Pin. Similar to the PAX East/Prime pins, this will be available for sale in limited quantities (until sold out) at the merch booth. Inventory is split daily, so line up early at the merch booth to get this pin. This pin may be/become more rare than other Pax 10 pins, as all Aus pins tend to be.
Tycho Tot
Set: Prime Core 2013
Available for purchase at the Pax Prime 2013 merch booth.
Golden Twitch
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
2013 Aus Logo
Set: Aus Core 2013
Available for purchase at the Pax Aus 2013 merch booth. This was the first Aus PAX, and also the first year of Pinny Arcade. Not many of these sets were made, and they remain as some of the most sought after pins.
Praise Helix
Set: Aus Partners 2015
To get this pin, be one of the first 300 guests in line for Twitch Town Hall panel Friday, October 30th, 4-5PM at the Wombat Theater. OR.. the first 50 people to play at the Twitch Corsair gaming arena will walk away with a Praise Helix pin everyday at booth #1116. Lastly, follow @twitch on Twitter for info on how to get the pin from Twitch staff, daily at 2PM.
Skull Logo Secret
Set: Aquisitions Incorporated
Available by purchasing the Aquisitions Inc blind box set from the PA online store. Winter 2016.
Leeroy Jenkins
Set: East Partners 2014
To get the Leeroy Jenkins pin, PAX East 2014 attendees had to be on the lookout for Leeroy to run through the crowd. After tracking him down and yelling at him enough, you would get his pin. Getting this pin took a lot of time and effort, and the process was fairly unpopular.
Strip Search
Set: Prime Partners 2013
Available from any of the Strip Search cast members at Prime 2013 and other public events. Each cast member was given 100 pins to distribute at they pleased. Some were sold, some traded, some hoarded.
Cinnabon Gabe
Set: Armadeaddon
Part of the Armadeaddon 2015 set released in Oct 2015 on the PA Store as a series of blind boxes. Given the relative difficulty of outright purchasing these pins, the whole set is likely to be highly tradable. Cinnabon Gabe had a drop frequency of 1/50 and so was one of the most rare pins in the set.
Ellie
Set: East Partners 2014
Available at the Playstation booth, PAX East 2014.
Carl Swangee
Set: Automata 2014
The Carl pin was released as a limited edition in October 2014 to celebrate the Automata Silverside series off strips. The pin was limited to 1,500 pieces and sold out within a few hours. Carl has long been a PA fan favorite, so expect this pin to be highly desired going forward.
Gold Rex Ready
Set: Staff 2018 - Chase
Available by trading in-person, in the wild, with Dave or Patrick at PAX East 2018. (Not traded at pin-trading events, you need to track them down on foot!) Design by Nick Trujillo.
Gold CTS
Set: Staff 2018 - Chase
Available by trading in-person, in the wild, with Erick, Dabe, Kiko, or Patrick at PAX East 2018. (Not traded at pin-trading events, you need to track them down on foot!) Design by Nick Trujillo.
Prof. Pigglesworth
Set: Prime Partners 2013
Available from Loading Ready Run at PAX Prime 2013.
Twitch Glitch
Set: East Partners 2015
Available daily to the first 50 people in line to play Heros of the Storm at the Twitch booth. Follow @twitch on twitter for updates on how it will be otherwise available during East. Pin will also be available at the Twitch Town Hall event (Sat 730PM, Albatross Theatre.
Vault Boy
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at the Bethesda Booth #2030. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Hearthstone Cards
Set: East Partners 2014
Avaialble at the Blizzard booth.
Automata Kickstarter 2
Set: Limited Ed 2015
Available by supporting the Summer 2015 Automata Kickstarter project at the $150 level (and then adding a $25 add-on for the bonus pin). These kickstarter pins are likely to be very limited, and highly collectible.
Gato Roboto
Set: South Partners 2019
The Gato Roboto Pin will be available to purchase in the merch area of the Devolver Digital booth #11060.
Kemper Kart
Set: Aus Core 2016
Available at the Merch booth at PAX Aus 2016
Aus Tycho
Set: Aus Core 2013
Available for purchase at the Pax Aus 2013 merch booth. This was the first Aus PAX, and also the first year of Pinny Arcade. Not many of these sets were made, and they remain as some of the most sought after pins. Probably the rarest Gabe and Tycho character pins.
Kemper Ghost
Set: Christmas 2014
For sale online at the PA Shop for a limitied time in Winter 2014. Characters in this set are inspired by Charles Dickens Christmas Carol.
The Order: 1066
Set: Prime Partners 2014
Available (theoretically) at the Playstation booth at PAX Prime 2014. This was generally agreed to be the hardest pin to get at Prime, due to long lines and the random nature of receiving the pin.
Prime 2015 Kemper
Set: Prime Core 2015
Available for purchase for $30 at the Pax Prime 2015 merch booth.
Stocking Kemper
Set: Christmas 2013
Available for sale at the online PA Store for a limited but lengthy time in 2013/2014. No longer available, but readily found through trading.
PAX Unplugged LE 2017
Set: PAX Unplugged 2017
Available at PAX Unplugged.
PAX West LE 2018
Set: West Core 2018
ONLY available at the Sheraton Lobby PAX Merch Booth, PAX West 2018.
Table Top Tycho
Set: East Core 2013
Available for purchase at the Pax East 2013 merch booth.
Tiamat
Set: Prime Partners 2014
Available only after the Acquisitions Inc show at PAX Prime 2014.
Edith Finch
Set: South Partners 2017
Attendees who complete a playthrough of the Edith Finch demo at Annapurna Interactive Booth #11022 will recieve a pin.
8 Bit Kemper
Set: PAX South 2018
Available at PAX South 2018.
15th Anniversary
Set: 15th Anniversary 2013
Limited to 2,000 pieces, this pin quickly sold out. Your best bet for this pin is to get lucky with a staff trade, as collectors wont often part with it. The characters in the pin represent the shift in art styles over the last 15 years of Penny Arcade.
Star
Set: Prime Partners 2013
Available as a random participation prize at Behemoths booth at PAX Prime 2013. Getting one was easy, getting them all÷ not so much.
Baby Gabe
Set: Prime Core 2013
Available for purchase at the Pax Prime 2013 merch booth.
Desert Bus For Hope
Set: Misc 2016
Included in auctions during DB4H10 in Winter 2016.
PAX East 10th Year
Set: Merch Exclusive 2014
Available at the East 2014 Merch booth, to celebrate the 10th anniversary of PAX. Only 1,200 were made, and all of them sold. Different flavors will be available at each PAX in 2014.
Kemper Crockett
Set: South Core 2015
Part of the Core 2015 South set, available for purchase at the merch booth.
Lymirth
Set: West Partners 2016
The pins are being given away at the D&D area on the 2nd floor of the Annex. Anyone who plays in an Acquisitions Inc adventure or in a Storm King’s Thunder D&D adventure will get a pin.
South 2015 Polygon
Set: Merch Exclusive 2015
A Limited Edition pin to commemorate PAX South 2015 (inaugural year!) in San Antonio. 1,500 were printed, available at the Lite Merch booth. Stock will be split 600/600/300 on Fri/Sat/Sun respectively.
Halo Legendary Crate
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for purchase at the Loot Crate booth #6516.
Diablo’s Pin of Sin
Set: West Partners 2018
Available at the Nintendo of America booth #1939.
Cuphead
Set: West Partners 2018
Collect stamps by completing demos at the Microsoft booth #403 that can be redeemed for a pin at the Xbox merch booth.
Fortnite Llama
Set: West Partners 2018
Receive a Fortnite Battle Royale 4 Pin Set by playing a full round of Lazy Links mini-golf located in the Annex, Level 1.
Kemper Bar
Set: Summer Treats
Available from the PA Online store starting in Summer 2017.
Nissa
Set: Aus Partners 2015
Available at the Magic the Gathering Booth in the Tabletop area.
Super Leaf
Set: Super Mario Bros. 3
From the SMB3 blind box set available on the PA Online store in 2017/2018.
East 2015 Polygon
Set: Merch Exclusive 2015
A Limited Edition pin to commemorate PAX East 2015. Available each morning at the merch booth, on a first-come-first-served basis. If similar to prior years, likely about 1,500 will be printed, with roughly 500 available per day. These always sell out quickly. ONLY available at the Merch Lite booth.
New Years 2015
Set: New Years 2015
Limited edition holiday pin available on the PA online store on Jan 1, 2015. Only 2,015 pins were produced. While these did not sell out as quickly as some other limited editions, all Gabe & Tycho pins make for popular trades, so expect this pin to be desirable. Pin designed by Gavin Greco.
8 Bit Upside Down Kemper
Set: Aus 2018 Core
Available at both PAX Merch Booths which are located in the Exhibition Centre.
Lookouts Kemper
Set: Halloween 2015
Available for sale at the PA Online store.
MTG Ugin
Set: South Partners 2015
Available as a prize from the Magic The Gathering tabletop area, Exhibit Hall D. This pin was the toughest to get from South 2015.
KI Fightstick
Set: Killer Instinct
The first PinUltimate set, these pins are available by completing certain online tasks/challenges in Killer Instinct on the Xbox One, and subsequently sold individually for $14.99 on the PA online store.
Chandra 2
Set: Aus Partners 2013
Available from the WotC booth at Aus 2013. This pin is probably just as rare as the other Aus 2013 pins, but less sought after since its not PA characters.
PAX East 2018 LE
Set: East 2018
For sale at the Merch Lite booth at PAX East 2018.
Colonial Kemper
Set: East Core 2014
Available for purchase at the Pax East 2014 merch booth.
Pizza X
Set: PAX South 2019 LE
ONLY available at the Lobby PAX Merch booth. Part of a P-A-X set.
PAX Unplugged LE 2018
Set: Unplugged 2018 Core
ONLY available at the Level 2 lobby PAX Merch Booth.
Valentines Day
Set: Valentines Day 2014
Limited to 1,500 pins, these sold out from the PA online store.
The Cat Aquatic
Set: West Core 2017
Available for purchase from the PAX West merch booth.
Dauntless
Set: West Partners 2017
Available at the Phoenix Labs booth #2335 - The demo will feature 3 different, 15-20 minute PvE battles. If someone wins the battle they get a pin.
Triad Wars
Set: Misc 2016
What to say about this pin? Triad Wars is an online MMO that was announced (in Dec 2015) to be cancelled (in Jan 2016). Then during PAX South (Jan 2016) a few of these pins leaked into the wild. Its likely that 1,000 of these exist - but unknown when, how, or if, they will ever be released.
Polaroid
Set: Armadeaddon
Part of the Armadeaddon 2015 set released in Oct 2015 on the PA Store as a series of blind boxes. Given the relative difficulty of outright purchasing these pins, the whole set is likely to be highly tradable. This Polaroid pin had an unknown drop frequency (rumored to be 1/75), and so was one of the most rare pins in the set.
PA 20 Yr
Set: Misc 2018
Celebrating PAs 20th Anniversary. Available for purchase online in Nov 2018.
Elder Scrolls Sweet Roll
Set: Aus 2018 Partners
Trade pins for the Holy Sweet Roll pin with some of the members of the Bethesda ANZ team and ‘Pin Trading with Pete. Pins will also be randomly given away from the First Church of the Holy Sweet Roll via special blessings and to the first 100 attendees at the Bethesda in Conversation and Bethesda Trivia panels.
PAX South 2018 LE
Set: PAX South 2018
Available at PAX South 2018. Limited Edition. Moving parts!
Coffee Kemper
Set: Prime Core 2014
Part of the Prime 2014 Core set. Available for purchase at the merch booth, South Lobby of the main Expo Hall.
Childs Play 15th Anniversary
Set: PAX South 2018
Available at PAX South 2018.
Sparkle Kitty
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
Dammit, Roach!
Set: East Partners 2016
Available at the QWENT-Ception panel, Saturday 2:30PM - Dragonfly Theatre.
PAX South Inaugural
Set: South Core 2015
Part of the Core 2015 South set, available for purchase at the merch booth.
Luna Owl
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
Mysterion
Set: West Partners 2016
Get a photo at the Ubisoft Booth #605 to get a pin. Pins will also be available at the South Park: The Fractured But Whole Panel on Friday, 3:00pm in Wyvern Theatre.
Monster Hunter World
Set: West Partners 2017
Receive one pin after completion of the Monster Hunter: World demo at Capcom booth #2109.
Dogmeat
Set: East Partners 2016
Available at the Bethesda booth #8021.
Cthulhu Dice
Set: Prime Partners 2014
Available at Kris Straubs booth at PAX Prime 2014.
Skull Logo
Set: Aquisitions Incorporated
Available by purchasing the Aquisitions Inc blind box set from the PA online store. Winter 2016.
Green Flame Fist
Set: West Partners 2016
The pins are being given away at the D&D area on the 2nd floor of the Annex. Anyone who plays in an Acquisitions Inc adventure or in a Storm King’s Thunder D&D adventure will get a pin.
Play Games Feel Better
Set: South Partners 2019
Available for purchase at the the Childs Play Charity Booth #12688.
Dangerous Space Time
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at booth #3017. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Beemo
Set: Prime Partners 2014
Part of the We Love Fine pin set at PAX Prime 2014.
Elspeth
Set: Prime Partners 2013
Avaialble at partner booths at Pax Prime 2013.
Master Sword
Set: Online 2017
Available at Pax Aus 2017 and online.
10 Year Geralt
Set: West Partners 2017
Available at the Celebrating the 10th Anniversary of The Witcher panel, Sunday 12pm - Main Theatre.
Prime 2015 Polygon
Set: Merch Exclusive 2015
Available for purchase for $30 at the Pax Prime 2015 merch LITE booth. As always, this will sell out early in the morning each day of the show
Club PA Year One
Set: Club PA 2014
Available by joining Club PA in 2014 at the $30/6mo level.
Trash King
Set: West Partners 2018
Available at the Annapurna Games booth #11040. Complete the Donut County demo to acquire the TRASH KING pin.
PAX Unplugged 2017 Logo
Set: PAX Unplugged 2017
Available at PAX Unplugged.
Wilson
Set: Prime Partners 2014
Wilson was available at the Klei Entertainment booth at PAX Prime 2014.
Heli-Kemper
Set: East Core 2017
Available at both Merch booths.
Pizza P
Set: PAX South 2019 LE
ONLY available at the Lobby PAX Merch booth. Part of a P-A-X set.
Iced Coffee Kemper
Set: East Core 2015
Part of the core 2015 East set, available for purchase from the merch booth.
Foxtrot Paige GG
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for purchase at the Bill Amend table in Bandland.
Nuka Cola Cap
Set: East Partners 2017
Available at the Bethesda Booth #20001 & #18007.
Youseeks VR
Set: West Partners 2016
Gotten by playing the demo - Adult Swim Games room 605 & 610. Limit to 200 per day.
Star Trek Online
Set: West Partners 2018
Available at Perfect World Entertainment’s Booth #1115. Take a photo in the Star Trek Captain’s Chair. Play one of our games. Share your email. Earn a pin! Make sure to first grab a postcard at the front desk to track all three required tasks and submit to receive the pin.
Gingerbread Kemper
Set: Christmas 2015
Part of the Christmas 2015 set, for sale on the online PA store.
Zombie Juice
Set: Armadeaddon
Part of the Armadeaddon 2015 set released in Oct 2015 on the PA Store as a series of blind boxes. Given the relative difficulty of outright purchasing these pins, the whole set is likely to be highly tradable. Zombie Juice had a 1/20 drop frequency, making it very uncommon in the set.
Hot Dog Fairy
Set: East Core 2014
Available for purchase at the Pax East 2014 merch booth.
Good Enough
Set: Aquisitions Incorporated
Available by purchasing the Aquisitions Inc blind box set from the PA online store. Winter 2016.
Golden Acron
Set: Aus 2018 Partners
Available for purchase at the Kris Straub table in Bandland.
PAX Aus Early Bird 2016
Set: Limited Ed 2016
This pin was gifted to anyone who purchased a 3 day PAX Aus badge prior to June 15, 2016.
South 19 Kemper
Set: PAX South 2019 Core
Available at the Official PAX Merch booths located in the Expo Hall and the Lobby.
Shadow Council
Set: Misc 2019
First available at the PAX South 2019 Merch booth, later made available on the online store.
Spoopbucks
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for purchase at the LoadingReadyRun table in Bandland.
Brutal Legend
Set: West Partners 2016
Available for $15 at the Double Fine Booth #106.
PAX West 2017 LE
Set: Merch Exclusive 2017
Only available for purchase at the PAX Merch Lite booth - supplies will be limited and split by day.
Floop The Pig
Set: Prime Partners 2014
Part of the We Love Fine pin set at PAX Prime 2014.
Crossy Mickey
Set: Aus 2017 Partners
Available at Pax Aus 2017.
Acquisitions Inc Logo
Set: Acquisitions Inc.
Available for sale at the online PA Store for a limited but lengthy time in 2013/2014. No longer available, but readily found through trading.
Cardinal
Set: Prime Partners 2013
Available as a random participation prize at Behemoths booth at PAX Prime 2013. Getting one was easy, getting them all÷ not so much.
Spoopy
Set: West Partners 2018
Available for purchase at the LaodingReadyRun table in Bandland.
Double Fine Raz
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at the Double Fine Booth #117. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Game Wizard Garfield
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for purchase at the Toonhound Studios booth #7609.
Crossy Chicken
Set: Aus 2017 Partners
Available at Pax Aus 2017.
SC Pinata
Set: Aus 2018 Partners
Available for purchase at the Samurai Punk booth PR08.
PAX East 2016 LE
Set: Merch Exclusive 2016
Only available at the PAX Merch Lite booth.
Fellow Traveller
Set: Aus 2018 Partners
Available for purchase at the Fellow Traveller booth PR12.
Overwatch Emblem
Set: East Partners 2015
Available from Blizzard (booth 8116) for playing the Overwatch demo.
Kemperoo
Set: Aus Core 2014
Part of the Pax Aus 2014 core set. Only available from the Merch booth at Pax Aus 2014.
Gold Grace
Set: Staff 2018 - Chase
Available by trading in-person, in the wild, with Kristin, Dora, or Laura at PAX East 2018. (Not traded at pin-trading events, you need to track them down on foot!) Design by Nick Trujillo.
Mario Kart Rose Gold Peach
Set: Mario Kart Blind Box 2018
This is part of the Mario Kart Racer Blind Box set. Random boxes of 2 pins each were sold online for $20 a box or $220 for a case of 12. This was the most rare drop in the blind boxes. Odds of receiving one were not published.
AI 10 Yr
Set: Misc 2018
Celebrating Aquisition Incs 10th Anniversary. Available for purchase online in Nov 2018.
Overcooked
Set: West Partners 2018
Collect stamps by completing demos at the Team17 booth #6011 that can be redeemed for a pin.
Harbinger
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
Dr. Whiskers
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for purchase at the Dire Wolf Digital booth #7405.
Mighty Machine
Set: Aus 2017 Partners
Available at Pax Aus 2017.
Firewatch Forrest Byrnes
Set: East Partners 2017
Available at the Campo Santo Booth #15096.
Thimbleweed Park
Set: West Partners 2016
Available at the Terrible Toybox Booth #848 (Indie Megabooth).
Bowser
Set: Super Mario Bros. 3
From the SMB3 blind box set available on the PA Online store in 2017/2018.
Shooty Cutie Cat
Set: Aus 2017 Partners
Available at Pax Aus 2017.
ToeJam & Earl
Set: West Partners 2016
Gotten by taking a photo with Big Earl on the floor, and playing the demo in the Adult Swim Games room (605 & 610). Limit to 200 per day.
Rex Ready
Set: Staff 2018
Available by trading in-person with Gavin or Ryan in 2018. Design by Nick Trujillo.
Vault Girl
Set: East Partners 2016
Available at the Bethesda booth #8021.
Vlambeer Logo
Set: West Partners 2018
Available at Vlambeer booth #6115.
Coon
Set: West Partners 2016
Get a photo at the Ubisoft Booth #605 to get a pin. Pins will also be available at the South Park: The Fractured But Whole Panel on Friday, 3:00pm in Wyvern Theatre.
Sheriff Spoopifer
Set: South Partners 2015
Available from the Loading Ready Run booth.
2013 Prime Logo
Set: Prime Core 2013
Available for purchase at the Pax Prime 2013 merch booth.
Starslip Prime
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at the Kris Straub table in Bandland. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Critically Queer
Set: Pride 2018
Available for purchase online in May 2018.
Cookie Brigade
Set: West Partners 2017
Need to find CC Brigade and purchase a pin!
PAX West 2016 LE
Set: Merch Exclusive 2016
Available for purchase from the PAX West (does Prime = West now? Ugh..) merch LITE booth. As always, quantities will be limited and split by day. Get to the merch lite booth early to get yours.
Skeleton Kemper
Set: Halloween 2016
Available at the PA Online Store Fall 2016
Weedonwantcha Cats
Set: Prime Partners 2014
Available at Katie Rices booth at PAX Prime 2014.
Flaming d20
Set: East Partners 2016
Available at the Thinkgeek booth #6188
Transformers
Set: East Partners 2017
Available at the Kabam Booth #12096. Come by the Transformers: Forged to Fight booth #12096 for a chance to win an exclusive Transformers: Forged to Fight Pinny Arcade Pin. Meet the development team for a game demo, try the “Beat the Boss” challenge, then spin the prize wheel to win the Pinny Arcade Pin or other cool prizes.
Gold Mr. Period
Set: Staff 2018 - Chase
Available by trading in-person, in the wild, with Lidija, Travis, Mike (Feh) or Dave at PAX East 2018. (Not traded at pin-trading events, you need to track them down on foot!) Design by Nick Trujillo.
Skeleton Jim
Set: Armadeaddon
Part of the Armadeaddon 2015 set released in Oct 2015 on the PA Store as a series of blind boxes. Given the relative difficulty of outright purchasing these pins, the whole set is likely to be highly tradable. Skeleton Jim had an unknown drop frequency, likely making it very rare in the set.
Mega Man
Set: West Partners 2018
Receive a Mega Man pin by completing the Mega Man 11 demo at the Capcom USA booth #2109.
80s Tycho
Set: Prime Core 2014
Part of the Prime 2014 Core set. Available for purchase at the merch booth, South Lobby of the main Expo Hall.
Jamie Dillion
Set: Staff 2014
Part of the 2014 Staff Pins set, revealed at Pax Prime 2014. Get this by trading with Jamie anytime.
Tabby Slime Rancher
Set: West Partners 2018
Available for purchase at the For Fans By Fans booth #7411.
Pizza A
Set: PAX South 2019 LE
ONLY available at the Lobby PAX Merch booth. Part of a P-A-X set.
Moonrise Nemony
Set: East Partners 2015
Get Nemony from the Undead Labs (booth 3092) If you have a Kitzapp (Prime 2014) or Emberjaw (South 2015) pin, you can use it to enter the daily tournament and earn a pin for playing.
PAX AUS Roadshow Koala
Set: West Partners 2016
Available at the Surprise Attack Games Booth #6312.
South 2017 LE
Set: Merch Exclusive 2017
Available for purchase from the merch LITE booth at PAX South 2017. As always, these pins are limited and rationed out each morning of the conference.
Zombie Tycho
Set: Staff 2012
Trade any pin with Tycho (Jerry) at PAX to get Zombie Tycho. This pin was available for trade all through 2013 and most of 2014, but starting Prime 2014 Tycho now trades for Helmet Tycho, so this pin may start becoming more rare.
Sarkhan, Unbroken
Set: East Partners 2015
Available as a prize on the Prize Wall in the MTG tournament space in the Tabletop Area. Hopefully not a pain in the neck like Ugin from South 2015.
Aus 2015 Polygon
Set: Merch Exclusive 2015
Limited edition pin commemorating PAX Aus 2015. As always, these will be limited in numbers and available only at the Merch Lite booth for the first few hours of each day.
Chainsaw Suit
Set: Prime Partners 2013
For sale at Kris Straubs booth at PAX Prime 2013.
Toad
Set: Super Mario Bros. 3
From the SMB3 blind box set available on the PA Online store in 2017/2018.
Link Triforce
Set: Misc 2017
Available from the PA Online store starting in Summer 2017.
Racoon Mario
Set: Super Mario Bros. 3
From the SMB3 blind box set available on the PA Online store in 2017/2018.
Camp W Skull
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at the Katie Rice table in Bandland. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Snow Level Kemper
Set: PAX Unplugged 2017
Available at PAX Unplugged.
Masquerada: The Heart
Set: PAX South 2018
Available at PAX South 2018.
PAX AUS Roadshow Echidna
Set: East Partners 2017
Available at the PAX AUS Roadshow Booth #13111.
Pinny Arcade Logo
Set: Misc
Originally available as trade with select Enforcers at any PAX.
Tanooki Mario
Set: Super Mario Bros. 3
From the SMB3 blind box set available on the PA Online store in 2017/2018.
Cactifer
Set: PAX South 2018
Available at PAX South 2018.
Gabe Kart
Set: Aus Core 2016
Available at the Merch booth at PAX Aus 2016
Jason/Quincy Card Chomp
Set: West Partners 2018
Available for purchase at the Bill Amend table in Bandland.
Garruk
Set: East Partners 2014
Available at the Wizards of the Coast booth.
PAX Aus 2016 LE
Set: Merch Exclusive 2016
Only available at the PAX Merch Lite Booth, PAX Aus 2016.
Half-Life Lambda
Set: East Partners 2016
Available at the Thinkgeek booth #6188
Shiva
Set: South Partners 2019
Play a demo of the game, The Walking Dead Something to Fear at the Skybound booth #11235 and receive a Shiva pin. 200 pins will be available each day with a limit of 1 per person per day.
VR Chippy
Set: PAX South 2018
Available at PAX South 2018.
PAX Prime Logo
Set: PAX Pronoun Set
First available for purchase at PAX East 2018. Designed by Gavin Greco.
Childs Play 2017
Set: South Partners 2017
Available for $20 each at the Child’s Play Booth #10485.
Neverwinter
Set: West Partners 2018
Available at Perfect World Entertainment’s Booth #1115. Play Neverwinter. Play a second game at our booth. Share your email. Earn a pin! Make sure to first grab a postcard at the front desk to track all three required tasks and submit to receive the pin.
PAX West 2017 Logo
Set: West Core 2017
Available for purchase from the PAX West merch booth.
TeeKO
Set: West Partners 2017
Available at the Jackbox Stage.
KI Logo
Set: Killer Instinct
The first PinUltimate set, these pins are available by completing certain online tasks/challenges in Killer Instinct on the Xbox One, and subsequently sold individually for $14.99 on the PA online store.
Kappa
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Be one of the first 200 guests in line for Twitch Town Hall panel Friday, August 25, 4-5PM at the Streaming Theater. Or, the first 50 people to play H1Z1 in the HP Omen gaming arena will walk away with one Kappa pin everyday at Twitch booth #3317. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Clank
Set: South Partners 2017
Available for $15 each at the Dire Wolf Digital Booth #10641. Will also be given away to players who win demo games throughout the weekend.
Rise of the Tribes
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
Dropbear
Set: Aus Core 2014
Part of the Pax Aus 2014 core set. Only available from the Merch booth at Pax Aus 2014.
Minecraft Diamond Block
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at the Thinkgeek Booth #SKY9. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Kurlbos Shoe Mario
Set: Super Mario Bros. 3
From the SMB3 blind box set available on the PA Online store in 2017/2018.
Giraffey
Set: Prime Partners 2013
Available as a random participation prize at Behemoths booth at PAX Prime 2013. Getting one was easy, getting them all÷ not so much.
N7 Mass Effect
Set: West Partners 2016
Available for $10 at the ThinkGeek Booth #SKY9.
Quincy
Set: West Partners 2016
Available at the Bill Amend Table in Bandland.
Club PA 2017
Set: Misc 2017
Available by joining Club PA in 2017.
Local 58
Set: South Partners 2019
Available for purchase at the Kris Straub table in Bandland.
Chandra
Set: East Partners 2013
Available from the WotC booth at East 2013. This was the first non-PA pin.
Paperville Panic UFO
Set: Aus 2017 Partners
Available at Pax Aus 2017.
Bastion
Set: East Partners 2015
Available from the Supergiant booth (8224).
Gorogoa
Set: East Partners 2017
Available at the Annapurna Interactive Booth #16121.
Portal Pin 3
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at the Valve Store in the We Love Fine Booth #7411. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Kaiju Stomp
Set: Aus 2018 Partners
Available for purchase at the Dime Studios booth PR28.
Legion
Set: West Partners 2016
Booth #425 to those who demo the game.
Hotstepper Gabe
Set: South Core 2015
Part of the Core 2015 South set, available for purchase at the merch booth. This design harkens back to the Kansis City Hotstepper PA comic side-story.
Rayman
Set: Prime Partners 2013
Avaialble at partner booths at Pax Prime 2013.
Teemo
Set: East Partners 2016
Available at The Riftwalk Room #153. Riot Games is distributing them to attendees as they exit The Riftwalk. They will not be for sale and will not be distributed at any other League location.
Transtar
Set: East Partners 2017
Available at the Bethesda Booth #20001 & #18007.
28 Plays Later
Set: Aus 2017 Partners
Available at Pax Aus 2017.
Anubis
Set: East Partners 2014
Available at the Age of Empires booth, PAX East 2014.
Nimbus
Set: Aus 2018 Partners
Available for purchase at the Queerly Represent Me table in the Diversity Lounge.
Statue Mario
Set: Super Mario Bros. 3
From the SMB3 blind box set available on the PA Online store in 2017/2018.
Enfu 1
Set: Enfu
Part of the 2015 Enfu set, should be available for purchase from the online PA store in November.
ETC
Set: Prime Partners 2014
Available from Blizzard at PAX Prime 2014.
Florence Female
Set: Aus 2017 Partners
Available at Pax Aus 2017.
Tyche
Set: Staff 2015
Trade any pin with Tycho (Jerry) at any PA public event to get this pin. First available at Prime 2014. Pins (and characters) designed by Mu.
Kissin Tycho
Set: Staff 2018
Available by trading in-person with Tycho (Jerry) in 2018.
Super Cutie
Set: Pride 2018
Available for purchase online in May 2018.
Popori
Set: West Partners 2018
Redeem En Masse coins that can be earned by completing activities at the En Masse Entertainment booth #7410.
ToeJam & Earl
Set: West Partners 2017
Available at the Adult Swim Games booth #1933 - Play the ToeJam & Earl: Back in the Groove demo.
PAX AUS Roadshow
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for purchase at the Surprise Attack booth #6312.
Owl Bear Pin
Set: West Partners 2016
Available at Cards Against Humanity.
Sarkhan
Set: Aus Partners 2014
Available from partner booths at PAX Aus 2014.
2014 East Logo
Set: East Core 2014
Available for purchase at the Pax East 2014 merch booth.
Drawful Owl
Set: West Partners 2016
Available at the Jackbox Stage in the WSCC International Court.
Club PA 2016
Set: Misc 2016
Available by joining Club PA in 2016.
Hatty Hattington
Set: Prime Partners 2013
Available as a random participation prize at Behemoths booth at PAX Prime 2013. Getting one was easy, getting them all÷ not so much.
Orwell
Set: Aus 2017 Partners
Available at Pax Aus 2017.
FoxTrot Peter Arcade
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
Twitch Arcade
Set: West Partners 2017
Grab a Twitch Pin Passport at Twitch Booth Front Desk at Booth 1909. Collect at least two stamps around the Twitch Booth. Redeem your Twitch Pinny Arcade Pin at the Twitch Booth Front Desk. Ways to Collect Stamps: Take a photo with the Glitch statue and share on social with the hashtag #TwitchatPAXWest. Meet your favorite streamer at our Meet & Greets. Play Shadowverse at the Cygames Game Zone. Check out new products from the Twitch Demo Zone and Twitch Prime. Limited pins available per day, only while supplies last. One card per person, per day.
Days Gone
Set: South Partners 2019
Available for purchase at the Sony booth #10458.
Splatter Annarchy
Set: Armadeaddon 2015
Part of the Armadeaddon 2015 set released in Oct 2015 on the PA Store as a series of blind boxes. Given the relative difficulty of outright purchasing these pins, the whole set is likely to be highly tradable. Splatter Annarchy had a 1/8 drop frequency, the most common in the set.
Flamin Hot Tycho
Set: Aus 2017 Core
Available at Pax Aus 2017.
Amplitude
Set: East Partners 2016
Available at the Harmonix Booth #6092. 100 pins will go to AbleGamers who will be auctioning off at their booth (tentative amount is $20 per pin). Harmonix will distribute Rock Band 4 and Amplitude pins to people who play songs at their booth - they are setting aside ~330 per day and anticipate running out between 3-4pm each day, assuming 5 pins per group.
Cat Guard
Set: Prime Partners 2013
Available as a random participation prize at Behemoths booth at PAX Prime 2013. Getting one was easy, getting them all÷ not so much.
Fleshreaper Kemper
Set: Merch Exclusive 2019
Available at the Official PAX Merch booths located in the Expo Hall and the Lobby with any purchase of $65 or more.
Mega Man
Set: West Partners 2016
Available for $10 at the ThinkGeek Booth #SKY9.
Tricentennial
Set: Misc 2018
First available for purchase from Bethesda, online in August 2018.
Victory Royale
Set: West Partners 2018
Receive a Fortnite Battle Royale 4 Pin Set by playing a full round of Lazy Links mini-golf located in the Annex, Level 1.
Legend of The Five Rings
Set: PAX Unplugged 2017
Available at PAX Unplugged.
Sworcery Deer
Set: West Partners 2018
Available for purchase at the CAPY booth #114.
Chain Chomp
Set: Super Mario Odyssey Capture Set 2018
First available for purchase online in Nov 2018.
Club PA 2018
Set: Misc 2018
Only available by being a member of Club PA during 2018.
Big Mario
Set: World 1-2 Set
Available from the PA Online store starting in Summer 2017.
Pixel
Set: Aus 2018 Partners
Available for sale at the CheckPoint table in the Diversity Lounge or alongside becoming a CheckPoint Patron of the $15 tier or above. All funds raised help continue our efforts to connect mental health resources with video games and technology.
Big Luigi
Set: Super Mario Bros. 3
From the SMB3 blind box set available on the PA Online store in 2017/2018.
Sunder
Set: South Partners 2019
Available for purchase at the Kitfox booth.
Talent Pipes
Set: Prime Partners 2014
Available the the Geek Chic booth at PAX Prime 2014.
2013 East Logo
Set: East Core 2013
Available for purchase at the Pax East 2013 merch booth.
Iron Horde
Set: Prime Partners 2014
Available from Blizzard at PAX Prime 2014.
Triple Town Bear
Set: Prime Partners 2014
Triple Town Bear was originally available at Spry Foxs booth at PAX Prime 2014.
Rage of Demons
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available to all attendees of the Acquisitions Incorporated Panel or at the Wizards of the Coast Booth #1642. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Green Flame
Set: Aquisitions Incorporated
Available by purchasing the Aquisitions Inc blind box set from the PA online store. Winter 2016.
8 Bit Upside Down Tycho
Set: Aus 2018 Core
Available at both PAX Merch Booths which are located in the Exhibition Centre.
Gingerbread Div
Set: Christmas 2015
Part of the Christmas 2015 set, for sale on the online PA store.
Platform Tycho
Set: South Core 2017
Available at both PAX Merch Booths, PAX South 2017. These pins were taken from the PAX South program cover, (a theme throughout the 2017 PAX core sets).
Pink Knight
Set: East Partners 2014
Available at the Behemoth booth, PAX East 2014.
GNOG
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for purchase at the Double Fine booth #106.
Hockey Spoop
Set: East Partners 2016
Available at the Loading Ready Run table in Bandland.
Mario Kart Shy Guy
Set: Mario Kart Blind Box 2018
This is part of the Mario Kart Racer Blind Box set. Random boxes of 2 pins each were sold online for $20 a box or $220 for a case of 12. The published odds of getting this pin are 1/10.
KRZ
Set: West Partners 2017
Available at the Annapurna Interacive booth #6908.
Warlock
Set: West Partners 2016
Available at the Bungie booth at PAX West 2016. Designed by Mike K.
Chicken Logo
Set: East Partners 2014
Available at the Behemoth booth, PAX East 2014.
Fortnite Logo
Set: West Partners 2018
Receive a Fortnite Battle Royale 4 Pin Set by playing a full round of Lazy Links mini-golf located in the Annex, Level 1.
Garruk (2)
Set: Prime Partners 2014
Available at the WotC booth at PAX Prime 2014. This pin completes the Garruk set. The left side of Garruk was released by WotC at Pax East 2014.
Troll Catsby
Set: South Core 2016
Available for purchase from the merch booth at PAX South 2016.
Chariot
Set: East Partners 2015
Available for $10 purchase from the Frima booth (10057).
Darksiders III
Set: West Partners 2018
Take a photo with your favorite Darksiders character or play a game demo at the THQ Nordic booth #2301 for the Darksiders III pin.
Bea
Set: South Partners 2019
Available for purchase at the Finji booth #10609.
Frog Mario
Set: Super Mario Bros. 3
From the SMB3 blind box set available on the PA Online store in 2017/2018.
Night in the Woods Gregg
Set: West Partners 2018
Available for purchase at the Finji booth #6210.
Double Fine Logo
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at the Double Fine Booth #117. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Donut County
Set: West Partners 2017
Available at the Annapurna Interacive booth #6908.
Cadavre
Set: East Partners 2016
Available at the Kris Straub table in Bandland.
Princess Toadstool
Set: Super Mario Bros. 3
From the SMB3 blind box set available on the PA Online store in 2017/2018.
Beholder
Set: PAX Unplugged 2017
Available at PAX Unplugged.
Titan
Set: West Partners 2016
Available at the Bungie booth at PAX West 2016. Designed by Mike K.
Red
Set: Prime Partners 2014
Red was originally for sale at the SuperGiant booth at PAX Prime 2014.
Tycho
Set: Core Online Set 2013
Part of the original core pin pack, released in 2012 and retired in summer 2015. Likely to remain very common for quite some time.
Gideon
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available on the Magic the Gathering Prize Wall as well as the Battle for Zendiker event on Saturday in the Annex. It will also be available at the PAX twitch panel and various social media opportunities.. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Bus Stop
Set: Misc 2018
Sold online for $25, profits benefitting Childs Play.
Mixtape
Set: Unplugged 2018 Partners
Available for purchase at the Breaking Games booth #2515.
Rose Gold Glitch
Set: West Partners 2018
Collect stamps by completing tasks at the Twitch booth #1909 that can be redeemed for a pin. Limited pins available per day, only while supplies last. Pins will also be available at the Twitch Town Hall panel on Friday, 10:30 am in Wyvern Theater.
Mario
Set: World 1-1 Set
Available at the PA Online Store Fall/Winter 2016.
Combo Breaker
Set: Killer Instinct
The first PinUltimate set, these pins are available by completing certain online tasks/challenges in Killer Instinct on the Xbox One, and subsequently sold individually for $14.99 on the PA online store.
CTS
Set: Staff 2012
Trade any pin with Gabe (Mike) at PAX to get CTS Gabe. This pin was available for trade all through 2013 and most of 2014, but starting Prime 2014 Gabe now trades for Broodax Gabe, so this pin may start becoming more rare.
Fluxx
Set: PAX Unplugged 2017
Available at PAX Unplugged.
Atoi
Set: Aus Partners 2014
Available from partner booths at PAX Aus 2014.
Behemoth Chicken Foot
Set: West Partners 2016
Available at The Behemoth Booth #1501, 1504, 1513.
Chaotic Nice
Set: Misc 2018
Available for purchase online in Nov 2018.
Claptrap
Set: West Partners 2016
Available at the We Love Fine Booth #7411
Psychomancer 2017
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for purchase at the Take This booth in the Diversity Lounge.
Golden Whale
Set: East Partners 2014
Available at the Behemoth booth, PAX East 2014.
Flamin Hot Fleshreaper
Set: Aus 2017 Core
Available at Pax Aus 2017.
Gwent Troll
Set: East Partners 2017
Available at the CD Projekt Red Panel, Saturday 1pm - Dragonfly Theatre.
CW Haunted Beaver
Set: South Partners 2016
Available at the Katie Rice table in Bandland, PAX South 2016.
Meat Boy
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for purchase at the Team Meat booth #835.
Childs Play 2016
Set: West Partners 2016
Available at the Child’s Play Charity Booth #N6 (North Lobby).
Spinal
Set: Killer Instinct
The first PinUltimate set, these pins are available by completing certain online tasks/challenges in Killer Instinct on the Xbox One, and subsequently sold individually for $14.99 on the PA online store.
Oculus Void
Set: West Partners 2018
Available at the Oculus stations in the VR Freeplay area located in the Westin, Level 4.
Flesh Reaper
Set: Core Online Set 2013
Part of the original core pin pack, released in 2012 and retired in summer 2015. Likely to remain very common for quite some time.
Bargain Quest Cat
Set: Unplugged 2018 Partners
Available for purchase at the Bargain Quest booth #2935 and the Renegade Games booth #2713.
Shovel Knight
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for purchase at the Yacht Club Games booth #433.
Armello Logo
Set: West Partners 2016
Available for $15 (cash only) at the PAX AUS Roadshow Booth #6211
Valeria
Set: South Partners 2019
Available for purchase at the Kitfox booth.
NYE 2017
Set: Limited 2017
Only available form the PA online store. 2,017 were made.
Hackernet
Set: Aus Partners 2016
Available for $20 AUD each at the Surprise Attack Games Stand PR10.
Small Mario
Set: Super Mario Bros. 3
From the SMB3 blind box set available on the PA Online store in 2017/2018.
Margarita
Set: Aus 2018 Partners
There will be daily giveaways with our “Beat the Devs Challenge” from 1pm - 2pm and the pins will also be available for purchase at the Giant Margarita booth PR31.
Emily
Set: West Partners 2016
Available for $10 at the PAX West 2016 at the Bethesda Booth #1102, 1303.
Bellringer Angel
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
Oculus South 19
Set: South Partners 2019
Obtain a Oculus Pin by completing a demo at the Oculus Rift room on Level 2 North and Oculus stations in VR Freeplay area on Level 3 or take a picture in front of the Stormland android, by the VR Freeplay area, post it on social media with the hashtags #oculus and #reclaimyourword.
Darkplace Brian
Set: Misc
This pin was originally offered as a reward for backing Katie Rices kickstarter campaign for Camp Weedonwantcha: Volume 1. While backers are likely to be the first to get this pin, Katie has said that it will also be available via other outlets in the future, though it wont ever be available for individual purchase.
Mario Kart Peach
Set: Mario Kart Blind Box 2018
This is part of the Mario Kart Racer Blind Box set. Random boxes of 2 pins each were sold online for $20 a box or $220 for a case of 12. The published odds of getting this pin are 1/10.
Split the Room Cat
Set: South Partners 2019
Available at the Jackbox Stage. You get a free pin if you win a game, or get one the easy way—by purchasing them for $15 each.
Rhythm Annarchy
Set: East Core 2016
Part of the core 2016 East set, only available for purchase from the merch booth.
Pax West 2016 Logo
Set: West Core 2016
Available for purchase from the PAX West (does Prime = West now?) merch booth.
Enfu Tycho
Set: Staff 2017
Trade with Tycho. First available at PAX East 2017.
Raccoon Monster
Set: East Partners 2015
Available from The Behemoth booth (5020). Pay $10 at their booth to receive (at random) one of their five pins. By asking really nicely, you may be able to trade them for a specific pin you still need.
Take This Castle
Set: West Partners 2018
Available at the Take This Hope booth in the Diversity Lounge with donation. All funds raised help continue our efforts at Take This.
PAX South 2016 LE
Set: Merch Exclusive 2016
Available for purchase from the merch booth at PAX South 2016. As always, quantities are limited and split out over each day of the conference. Follow @pinny_arcade for details and updates.
Snow Level Gabe
Set: PAX Unplugged 2017
Available at PAX Unplugged.
PAX Unplugged 2018 Logo
Set: Unplugged 2018 Core
Available at the Official PAX Merch Booths located in the Expo Hall and the Level 2 lobby.
Goomba
Set: World 1-1 Set
Available at the PA Online Store Fall/Winter 2016.
Game Over Mario
Set: Misc 2017
Available for purchase, for the first time, at both PAX West 2017 Merch Booths. Available on the Penny Arcade Store on September 13th, 2017.
Platform Gabe
Set: South Core 2017
Available at both PAX Merch Booths, PAX South 2017. These pins were taken from the PAX South program cover, (a theme throughout the 2017 PAX core sets).
Chainsawsuit Logo
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for purchase at the Kris Straub table in Bandland.
New Game +
Set: Pride 2018
Available for purchase online in May 2018.
Fortnite Bush
Set: West Partners 2018
Receive a Fortnite Battle Royale 4 Pin Set by playing a full round of Lazy Links mini-golf located in the Annex, Level 1.
Pie Kristin
Set: Staff 2017
Trade with Kristin. First available at PAX East 2017.
Catbug
Set: Prime Partners 2014
Part of the We Love Fine pin set at PAX Prime 2014.
Mario Kart Bowser
Set: Mario Kart Blind Box 2018
This is part of the Mario Kart Racer Blind Box set. Random boxes of 2 pins each were sold online for $20 a box or $220 for a case of 12. The published odds of getting this pin are 1/20.
The C Team TPK
Set: PAX South 2018
Available at PAX South 2018.
Splatter Tycho
Set: Armadeaddon 2015
Part of the Armadeaddon 2015 set released in Oct 2015 on the PA Store as a series of blind boxes. Given the relative difficulty of outright purchasing these pins, the whole set is likely to be highly tradable. Splatter Tycho had a 1/8 drop frequency, the most common in the set.
Flamin Hot Gabe
Set: Aus 2017 Core
Available at Pax Aus 2017.
Moonrise Emberjaw
Set: South Partners 2015
Get this pin for free (for playing a game demo) at the Undead Labs booth. Moonrise has stated that this pin is the first in a special set of three.
Finn
Set: Prime Partners 2014
Part of the We Love Fine pin set at PAX Prime 2014.
Prime 2014 Logo
Set: Prime Core 2014
Part of the Prime 2014 Core set. Available for purchase at the merch booth, South Lobby of the main Expo Hall.
Tizo
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
Skeleton Tycho
Set: Halloween 2016
Available at the PA Online Store Fall 2016
Jin
Set: Prime Partners 2013
Avaialble at partner booths at Pax Prime 2013.
Keys
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
Zelda Triforce
Set: Misc 2017
Available from the PA Online store starting in Summer 2017.
FoxTrot Jason d20
Set: East Partners 2017
Available at the Bill Amend table in Bandland.
Fracture the Cat
Set: West Partners 2018
Available for purchase at the Kris Straub table in Bandland.
Jeff - A Real Wizard
Set: Aquisitions Incorporated
Available by purchasing the Aquisitions Inc blind box set from the PA online store. Winter 2016.
Tourist Gabe
Set: East Core 2015
Part of the core 2015 East set, available for purchase from the merch booth.
Spectrum Medallion
Set: Unplugged 2018 Partners
Available for purchase in the Diversity Lounge.
Wraith
Set: East Partners 2016
Available at The Behemoth Booth #4025.
Jago
Set: Killer Instinct
The first PinUltimate set, these pins are available by completing certain online tasks/challenges in Killer Instinct on the Xbox One, and subsequently sold individually for $14.99 on the PA online store.
Witch Annarchy
Set: Halloween 2013
Available for sale at the online PA Store for a limited but lengthy time in 2013/2014. No longer available, but readily found through trading.
Wrapped Div
Set: Christmas 2013
Available for sale at the online PA Store for a limited but lengthy time in 2013/2014. No longer available, but readily found through trading.
What Ho!
Set: East Partners 2016
Available in the Kickstarter room #103.
Rock Band 2015
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available to attendees that play Rock Band at the Harmonix Booth #152. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Santa Gabe
Set: Christmas 2013
Available for sale at the online PA Store for a limited but lengthy time in 2013/2014. No longer available, but readily found through trading.
STEVe
Set: West Partners 2016
Bring your Steam or PS4 Blade Ballet email receipt to Booth 752 to claim your STEVe Pinny Arcade Pin. Pins will also be given away as prizes during tournaments. Indie Megabooth 752.
New Year 2016
Set: Limited Ed 2016
Released for New Years 2016. Accordingly, 2,016 of these pins were made - which is relativly large for a limited set.
Iron Guard Stance
Set: East Core 2014
Available for purchase at the Pax East 2014 merch booth.
Lookouts Crest
Set: Lookouts
For sale at the online PA Store. These pins are the cheapest you can buy on a per-pin basis, and so are often bought in bulk as trade fodder with PA Staff for better pins.
8 Bit Fleshreaper
Set: West Core 2018
Available at the PAX Merch Booths (West 2018) located in the WSCC Atrium Lobby and the Sheraton Lobby.
Kemper 1
Set: Kemper Summer 2016
Available for purchase from the PA online store, summer 2016.
Ghost
Set: West Partners 2016
Available at the Bungie booth at PAX West 2016. Designed by Mike K.
Drop Dice Bear
Set: Aus 2018 Partners
Available for purchase at the Level Up Dice booth TT220.
Florence Male
Set: Aus 2017 Partners
Available at Pax Aus 2017.
Helpful Keg Robot
Set: Aquisitions Incorporated
Available by purchasing the Aquisitions Inc blind box set from the PA online store. Winter 2016.
Dry Bones
Set: Super Mario Bros. 3
From the SMB3 blind box set available on the PA Online store in 2017/2018.
Annarchy Wreath
Set: Christmas 2016
Available by purchasing from the PA online store, Winter 2016.
Banner Saga 2
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at the Versus Evil Booth #6608. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Trivial Murder Party
Set: East Partners 2017
Available at the Jackbox Stage.
Tycho Sketch 1
Set: Sketch Set
First available at SDCC 2014, and subsequently sold online at the PA Store.
Mimic
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for purchase at the ThinkGeek booth #Skybridge-9.
CTS
Set: Staff 2018
Available by trading in-person with Erick in 2018. Design by Nick Trujillo.
Erika Sadsad
Set: Staff 2013
Find Erika at PAX or other public PA events - trade any pin with her to receive her pin. Starting with PAX Prime 2014, this staff set was retired and replaced with the symbols staff set. Pin design by Tavis Maiden.
Merch
Set: Merch
Available at any PAX merch booth in 2013/2014 when spending more than $99. Replaced in 2014 by Merch 2.0
Boo
Set: Super Mario Bros. 3
From the SMB3 blind box set available on the PA Online store in 2017/2018.
Bug Splat
Set: Online
This pin was sold for $25 online, with the profits benefiting Childs Play. It was also given away as an additional prize for all auction and giveway winners during Desert Bus 11.
Axe
Set: West Partners 2018
Available for purchase at the New Blood Interactive booth #6215.
Troll
Set: East Partners 2015
Available from The Behemoth booth (5020). Pay $10 at their booth to receive (at random) one of their five pins. By asking really nicely, you may be able to trade them for a specific pin you still need.
Kookaburra
Set: West Partners 2018
Available for purchase at the League of Geeks booth #6211.
Gnome
Set: East Partners 2016
Available at The Behemoth Booth #4025.
Zane and Mercy
Set: East Partners 2014
For sale at Kris Straubs booth, PAX East 2014.
Helmet Tycho
Set: Staff 2014
Trade any pin with Tycho (Jerry) at any PA public event to get this pin. First available at Prime 2014.
Thunder
Set: Killer Instinct
The first PinUltimate set, these pins are available by completing certain online tasks/challenges in Killer Instinct on the Xbox One, and subsequently sold individually for $14.99 on the PA online store.
Doom Revenant
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at the Bethesda Booth #2030. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Kemper 2
Set: Kemper Summer 2016
Available for purchase from the PA online store, summer 2016.
Outer Wilds
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
You Don’t Know Jack
Set: West Partners 2018
Available at the Jackbox Stage.
Popper
Set: Aus 2018 Partners
There will be daily giveaways with our “Beat the Devs Challenge” from 1pm - 2pm and the pins will also be available for purchase at the Giant Margarita booth PR31.
Skeleton Gabe
Set: Halloween 2016
Available at the PA Online Store Fall 2016
Mesozooic
Set: Unplugged 2018 Partners
Play a demo of Mesozooic at the Z-Man Games booth #2701 to receive the pin.
Core 2 Gabe
Set: Core 2.0
The original Core pin set was available online for 3 years, and served as the foundational building blocks for Pinny Arcade. That set was retired in summer 2015 and replaced with Core 2.0. This set is available at the online PA store, and these pins will likely become quite common.
The Shared Dream Faces
Set: Unplugged 2018 Partners
Available for purchase at the ODAM Publishing booth #2033.
VR Tycho
Set: West Core 2016
Available for purchase from the PAX West (does Prime = West now? Ugh..) merch booth.
Weedonwantcha Purdy
Set: East Partners 2015
The Purdy Pin can be found at Katie RiceÌs table in Bandland.
Kiko Villasenor
Set: Staff 2013
Find Kiko at PAX or other public PA events - trade any pin with him to receive his pin. Starting with PAX Prime 2014, this staff set was retired and replaced with the symbols staff set. Pin design by Tavis Maiden.
Catsby
Set: Twisp & Catsby
Available for sale at the online PA Store.
Arbitrix
Set: Aus 2018 Partners
Available for purchase at the Tin Man Games booth PR10.
Sad Zombie Tycho
Set: Armadeaddon
Part of the Armadeaddon 2015 set released in Oct 2015 on the PA Store as a series of blind boxes. Given the relative difficulty of outright purchasing these pins, the whole set is likely to be highly tradable. Sad Zombie Tycho had a 1/20 drop frequency, making it very uncommon in the set.
Aus 2014 Logo
Set: Aus Core 2014
Part of the Pax Aus 2014 core set. Only available from the Merch booth at Pax Aus 2014.
Night in the Woods
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
BadgeTycho
Set: South Core 2015
Part of the Core 2015 South set, available for purchase at the merch booth.
Mummy Gabe
Set: Halloween 2013
Available for sale at the online PA Store for a limited but lengthy time in 2013/2014. No longer available, but readily found through trading.
Jim Darkmagic
Set: Acquisitions Inc.
Available for sale at the online PA Store for a limited but lengthy time in 2013/2014. No longer available, but readily found through trading.
Fire Mario
Set: Super Mario Bros. 3
From the SMB3 blind box set available on the PA Online store in 2017/2018.
Mario Kart Donkey Kong
Set: Mario Kart Blind Box 2018
This is part of the Mario Kart Racer Blind Box set. Random boxes of 2 pins each were sold online for $20 a box or $220 for a case of 12. The published odds of getting this pin are 1/20.
Portal Pin 1
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at the Valve Store in the We Love Fine Booth #7411. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Sunhat Kthriss
Set: PAX South 2018
Available at PAX South 2018.
Robert Khoo
Set: Staff 2013
Find Khoo at PAX or other public PA events - trade any pin with him to receive his pin. Starting with PAX Prime 2014, this staff set was retired and replaced with the symbols staff set. Pin design by Tavis Maiden.
Tin Man Games
Set: Aus Partners 2014
Available from partner booths at PAX Aus 2014.
Special Cup
Set: Mario Kart Classic Cups 2018
Available for purchase online in Nov 2018.
Doomguy
Set: Misc 2018
First available for purchase from Bethesda, online in August 2018.
Nigiri Ryan
Set: Staff 2017
Trade with Ryan. First available at PAX East 2017.
Tourist Tycho
Set: East Core 2015
Part of the core 2015 East set, available for purchase from the merch booth.
The Duel Skull
Set: PAX Unplugged 2017
Available at PAX Unplugged.
Queen of Smiles
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for purchase at the Ska Studios booth #6317.
New Year 2018
Set: Limited 2018
Available online at the Penny Arcade Store.
Mario Kart Rosalina
Set: Mario Kart Blind Box 2018
This is part of the Mario Kart Racer Blind Box set. Random boxes of 2 pins each were sold online for $20 a box or $220 for a case of 12. The published odds of getting this pin are 1/20.
Small Luigi
Set: Super Mario Bros. 3
From the SMB3 blind box set available on the PA Online store in 2017/2018.
South 19 Tycho
Set: PAX South 2019 Core
Available at the Official PAX Merch booths located in the Expo Hall and the Lobby.
Camp Weedonwantcha
Set: East Partners 2014
For sale at Katie Rices booth, PAX East 2014.
Super Meat Family
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
VA-11-Hall-A Jill
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
Diving Gabe
Set: West Core 2017
Available for purchase from the PAX West merch booth.
Broodhollow Iris
Set: South Partners 2015
Available from Kris Straub at his booth in Bandland.
The Adventure Pals Cupcake
Set: Aus 2018 Partners
Available for purchase at the Massive Monster booth PR09.
SW Action Figures
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for purchase at Katie Rice table in Bandland.
Honey Hug
Set: Prime Partners 2014
Cup Cake and Honey Hug were both available at the Behemoth booth at PAX Prime 2014.
Rhythm Cyn
Set: East Core 2016
Part of the core 2016 East set, only available for purchase from the merch booth.
Pit People 5
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at The Behemoth Booth #3004
Tuesday Knight
Set: Unplugged 2018 Partners
Available for purchase or with any purchase of $20 or more at the Tuesday Knight Games booth #2856.
Moonrise Kitzapp
Set: Prime Partners 2014
Available at the Undead Labs booth at PAX Prime 2014.
Supreme Victory
Set: Killer Instinct
The first PinUltimate set, these pins are available by completing certain online tasks/challenges in Killer Instinct on the Xbox One, and subsequently sold individually for $14.99 on the PA online store.
Robert Khoo
Set: Staff 2015
Part of the 2015 Staff Pins set, revealed at East 2015. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Khoo. Pin design by Katie Rice.
Hair Troll
Set: East Partners 2016
Available at The Behemoth Booth #4025.
Cheep Cheep
Set: Super Mario Odyssey Capture Set 2018
First available for purchase online in Nov 2018.
Brian Sunter
Set: Staff 2013
Find Brian at PAX or other public PA events - trade any pin with him to receive his pin. Starting with PAX Prime 2014, this staff set was retired and replaced with the symbols staff set. Pin design by Tavis Maiden.
Blockpocalypse Shark
Set: Aus 2017 Partners
Available at Pax Aus 2017.
Hammer Bro
Set: Super Mario Bros. 3
From the SMB3 blind box set available on the PA Online store in 2017/2018.
Creepy Doll BBQ
Set: South Partners 2016
Available at the Loading Ready Run table in Bandland, PAX South 2016.
Just Shapes and Beats
Set: PAX South 2018
Available at PAX South 2018.
Gingerbread Tycho
Set: Christmas 2015
Part of the Christmas 2015 set, for sale on the online PA store.
PVP Giddy Up
Set: South Partners 2015
Available from Scott Kurtz at his booth in Bandland.
Old Man
Set: Zelda 2017
First available at the Merch booth at PAX East 2017, later available at the PA Online store.
FarCry 5 Flag
Set: West Partners 2017
Available at the Ubisoft booth #605 - Reward for high score winners during contests or attendees will be able to get the pin at our panel at the Hydra Theatre that takes place on Saturday from 2:30PM - 3:30PM.
Enfu Panda
Set: East Partners 2017
Available at both PAX Merch Booths.
Sprite
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at the Runic Games Booth #6602. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Kthriss Holiday
Set: Christmas 2017
Available online at the Penny Arcade Store.
PAX South 2019 Logo
Set: PAX South 2019 Core
Available at the Official PAX Merch booths located in the Expo Hall and the Lobby.
Creepy Doll
Set: Prime Partners 2014
Available from the Loading Ready Run booth at PAX Prime 2014.
The Next Level
Set: Prime Partners 2014
Available at the Ubisoft booth at PAX Prime 2014.
Second Son
Set: Prime Partners 2013
Avaialble at partner booths at Pax Prime 2013.
Bubble Fish
Set: Unplugged 2018 Partners
Available for purchase the Lightseekers booth #3033.
Thrax
Set: South Partners 2017
Available for $15 each at the Toonhound Studios Booth #10071.
Jeff Kalles
Set: Staff 2013
Find Jeff at PAX or other public PA events - trade any pin with him to receive his pin. Starting with PAX Prime 2014, this staff set was retired and replaced with the symbols staff set. Pin design by Tavis Maiden.
Possum
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
Doggo
Set: Aus 2017 Partners
Available at Pax Aus 2017.
Pad Thai David
Set: Staff 2017
Trade with David. First available at PAX East 2017.
Hydra
Set: Aus Partners 2016
Available for $20 AUD each at the Armello Stand PR08.
Portal Pin 4
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at the Valve Store in the We Love Fine Booth #7411. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Bloody Bear
Set: Prime Partners 2013
Available as a random participation prize at Behemoths booth at PAX Prime 2013. Getting one was easy, getting them all÷ not so much.
Tycho Kart
Set: Aus Core 2016
Available at the Merch booth at PAX Aus 2016
Tobiko Dabe
Set: Staff 2017
Trade with Dabe. First available at PAX East 2017.
Lovebug
Set: West Partners 2016
Available at the Katie Rice Table in Bandland.
Mushroom Cup
Set: Mario Kart Classic Cups 2018
Available for purchase online in Nov 2018.
Volcano
Set: East Partners 2017
Available at the Bethesda Booth #20001 & #18007.
PAX Aus 2018 Logo
Set: Aus 2018 Core
Available at both PAX Merch Booths which are located in the Exhibition Centre.
Pumpkin Fruit Fu*ker
Set: Halloween 2013
Available for sale at the online PA Store for a limited but lengthy time in 2013/2014. No longer available, but readily found through trading.
Cute Samurai
Set: Aus 2017 Partners
Available at Pax Aus 2017.
Just Shapes & Beats
Set: South Partners 2019
Available for purchase at the Berzerk Studio booth #10255.
Alien Hominid
Set: East Partners 2014
Available at the Behemoth booth, PAX East 2014.
Gaytroller
Set: Pride 2018
Available for purchase online in May 2018.
Vampire Tycho
Set: Halloween 2013
Available for sale at the online PA Store for a limited but lengthy time in 2013/2014. No longer available, but readily found through trading.
Jeff Kalles
Set: Staff 2014
Part of the 2014 Staff Pins set, revealed at Pax Prime 2014. Get this by trading with Jeff anytime.
Star Cup
Set: Mario Kart Classic Cups 2018
Available for purchase online in Nov 2018.
Gabe Bar
Set: Summer Treats
Available from the PA Online store starting in Summer 2017.
Link
Set: Zelda 2017
First available at the Merch booth at PAX East 2017, later available at the PA Online store.
Club PA 2015
Set: Misc
Available by joining Club PA in 2015.
Broodax Gabe
Set: Staff 2014
Trade any pin with Gabe (Mike) at any PA public event to get this pin. First available at Prime 2014.
Gigantic Tyto
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at the Motiga Booth #3827. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Juggernaut
Set: Prime Partners 2013
Avaialble at partner booths at Pax Prime 2013.
Deep Crow
Set: Halloween 2014
For sale online at the PA Shop for a limitied time in Fall 2014.
PAX East 2017 Logo
Set: East Core 2017
Available at both Merch booths.
Enfu Gabe
Set: Staff 2017
Trade with Gabe. First available at PAX East 2017.
MC Frontalot Final Boss
Set: West Partners 2016
Available at the MC Frontalot Table in Bandland.
Lookouts Annarchy
Set: Halloween 2015
Available for sale at the PA Online store.
Seattle Polaris
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at the Maker Booth #3835. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Commander Bragh
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Checkout the demo for Star Wars Uprising and pre-register for the game at the Kabam Booth #111. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Kemper 4
Set: Kemper Summer 2016
Available for purchase from the PA online store, summer 2016.
Emu
Set: Aus Core 2014
Part of the Pax Aus 2014 core set. Only available from the Merch booth at Pax Aus 2014.
Capture Mario
Set: Super Mario Odyssey Capture Set 2018
First available for purchase online in Nov 2018.
Star Realms
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for purchase at the White Wizard Games booth #6702.
Bin it 2 Win it
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at the Toonhound Booth #S4. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Deathclaw
Set: West Partners 2016
Available for $10 at the PAX West 2016 at the Bethesda Booth #1102, 1303.
Mike Fehlauer
Set: Staff 2013
Find Mike at PAX or other public PA events - trade any pin with him to receive his pin. Starting with PAX Prime 2014, this staff set was retired and replaced with the symbols staff set. Pin design by Tavis Maiden.
Balloonicorn
Set: West Partners 2016
Available at the We Love Fine Booth #7411
Mallow Drops
Set: Aus Partners 2016
Available for $20 AUD each at the Gritfish Stand 24. Buy both Mallow Drops and Samurai Punk pins for $30.
Kemper 3
Set: Kemper Summer 2016
Available for purchase from the PA online store, summer 2016.
8-Bit Green Flame
Set: East 2018 Core
Part of the East Core 2018 set. Available for purchase at the Merch booth.
Hob
Set: East Partners 2016
Available at the Runic Games booth #7248.
Cup Cake
Set: Prime Partners 2014
Cup Cake and Honey Hug were both available at the Behemoth booth at PAX Prime 2014.
Gavin Greco
Set: Staff 2014
Part of the 2014 Staff Pins set, revealed at Pax Prime 2014. Get this by trading with Gavin anytime.
Friends in High Places
Set: Staff 2016
Part of the 2016 Staff pins set. First revealed at East 2016. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Gavin. From the PA strip titled Friends in High Places.
BOOgan Spoopifer
Set: Aus 2018 Partners
Available for purchase at the LoadingReadyRun table in Bandland.
Owlboy Otus
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for purchase at the We Love Fine booth #7411.
Gabbie
Set: Staff 2015
Trade any pin with Gabe (Mike) at any PA public event to get this pin. First available at East 2015. Pins (and characters) designed by Mu.
Enfu 3
Set: Enfu 2015
Part of the 2015 Enfu set, should be available for purchase from the online PA store in November.
Underground Goomba
Set: World 1-2 Set
Available from the PA Online store starting in Summer 2017.
8 Bit CTS
Set: West Core 2018
Available at the PAX Merch Booths (West 2018) located in the WSCC Atrium Lobby and the Sheraton Lobby.
Portal Pin 2
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at the Valve Store in the We Love Fine Booth #7411. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Gunny
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for purchase at the Samurai Punk booth #6215.
Bob-omb
Set: Super Mario Bros. 3
From the SMB3 blind box set available on the PA Online store in 2017/2018.
Tugger Nutts Goes Down Under
Set: Aus Partners 2016
Available at the LoadingReadyRun table in Bandland.
PAX East 2016 Logo
Set: East Core 2016
Part of the core 2016 East set, only available for purchase from the merch booth.
South 19 Gabe
Set: PAX South 2019 Core
Available at the Official PAX Merch booths located in the Expo Hall and the Lobby.
TF2 Scout
Set: East Partners 2015
For purchase at the Valve Store (booth 9212)
Headup 10 Year
Set: South Partners 2019
Headups awesome super-duper 10 year anniversary pins will be for sale for $15 at the Headup Games booth #10259
Tycho Scrooge
Set: Christmas 2014
For sale online at the PA Shop for a limitied time in Winter 2014. Characters in this set are inspired by Charles Dickens Christmas Carol.
Oculus
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
Rainbow Ridin Gabe
Set: East Core 2017
Available at both Merch booths.
Banner Saga 1
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at the Versus Evil Booth #6608. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
TF2 Spy
Set: East Partners 2015
For purchase at the Valve Store (booth 9212)
Levin Sadsad
Set: Staff 2014
Part of the 2014 Staff Pins set, revealed at Pax Prime 2014. Get this by trading with Levin anytime. Levin has left Penny Arcade, so this pin may be relativly rare.
Hunter
Set: West Partners 2016
Available at the Bungie booth at PAX West 2016. Designed by Mike K.
Merch 6.0
Set: Merch Exclusive 2018
Available for purchase at the merch booths at PAX 2018.
LRR Tugger Nutts
Set: West Partners 2016
Available at the LoadingReadyRun Table in Bandland.
Love Has No Labels
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for $15 each at the Love Has No Labels booth in the Diversity Lounge. Finish the new Love Has No Labels mobile game, League of Extraordinary Humans, to see if you’re a lucky pin winner! The game is available for download on the Apple App Store and Google play.
Panda Espresso
Set: Prime Partners 2014
Available at Scott Kurtzs booth at PAX Prime 2014.
Daxter
Set: Misc
Available for sale from the US Playstation online store.
Kenneth Kuan
Set: Staff 2014
Part of the 2014 Staff Pins set, revealed at Pax Prime 2014. Get this by trading with Kenneth anytime.
Rockband 4
Set: East Partners 2016
Available at the Harmonix Booth #6092. 100 pins will go to AbleGamers who will be auctioning off at their booth (tentative amount is $20 per pin). Harmonix will distribute Rock Band 4 and Amplitude pins to people who play songs at their booth - they are setting aside ~330 per day and anticipate running out between 3-4pm each day, assuming 5 pins per group.
Gabe of the Eyrewood
Set: Halloween 2015
Available for sale at the PA Online store.
Splatter Charles
Set: Armadeaddon 2015
Part of the Armadeaddon 2015 set released in Oct 2015 on the PA Store as a series of blind boxes. Given the relative difficulty of outright purchasing these pins, the whole set is likely to be highly tradable. Splatter Charles had a 1/10 drop frequency, making it somewhat uncommon in the set.
Alienware 20th Anniversary
Set: Aus Partners 2016
Giving out pins at the booth (Stand 1730) via on-stand competitions and through the Alienware Live Twitch channel.
Mafia 223rd
Set: West Partners 2016
Available at the Mafia III - Creating the Open World of New Bordeaux Panel on Saturday, 1:30pm in Hydra Theatre.
8-Bit Jim Darkmagic
Set: East 2018 Core
Part of the East Core 2018 set. Available for purchase at the Merch booth.
VA-11 Hall-A Dorothy
Set: West Partners 2018
Available for purchase at the Ysbryd Games booth #6808.
Merch Bar
Set: Summer Treats
Available from the PA Online store starting in Summer 2017.
Sinner Sacrifice for Redemption
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
Santas Little Helper
Set: Staff 2016
Part of the 2016 Staff pins set. First revealed at East 2016. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Robert. From the PA strip titled Santas Little Helper.
Satan
Set: South Partners 2019
Available for purchase at the tinyBuild booth #10669.
Project Spark
Set: East Partners 2014
Avaiable at the Project Spark booth, PAX East 2014.
French Fry Jeff
Set: Staff 2017
Trade with Jeff. First available at PAX East 2017.
Psychomancer
Set: Aus Partners 2016
Available for $20 AUD each at the Diversity Hub. All funds raised help continue our efforts to raise awareness about mental health.
Davey Crockett
Set: Prime Partners 2013
Available as a random participation prize at Behemoths booth at PAX Prime 2013. Getting one was easy, getting them all÷ not so much.
Unlock!
Set: PAX Unplugged 2017
Available at PAX Unplugged.
She/Her
Set: PAX Pronoun Set
First available for purchase at PAX East 2018. Designed by Gavin Greco.
Mad Scientist Tycho
Set: Halloween 2014
For sale online at the PA Shop for a limitied time in Fall 2014.
Mario Kart Daisey
Set: Mario Kart Blind Box 2018
This is part of the Mario Kart Racer Blind Box set. Random boxes of 2 pins each were sold online for $20 a box or $220 for a case of 12. The published odds of getting this pin are 3/40.
Kiko Villasenor
Set: Staff 2014
Part of the 2014 Staff Pins set, revealed at Pax Prime 2014. Get this by trading with Kiko anytime.
Fruit Fu*ker
Set: Core Online Set 2013
Part of the original core pin pack, released in 2012 and retired in summer 2015. Likely to remain very common for quite some time.
They/Them
Set: PAX Pronoun Set
First available for purchase at PAX East 2018. Designed by Gavin Greco.
Hangar 13
Set: East Partners 2016
Available at the Mafia 3 panel, Saturday 12:00PM - Bumble Bee Theater.
KThriss Drowb
Set: Aquisitions Incorporated
Available by purchasing the Aquisitions Inc blind box set from the PA online store. Winter 2016.
GNN Robot
Set: East Partners 2016
Available at the Master of Orion Panel at 3pm on Saturday in Albatross, to the first 1,000 guests.
UltraTech Logo
Set: Killer Instinct
The first PinUltimate set, these pins are available by completing certain online tasks/challenges in Killer Instinct on the Xbox One, and subsequently sold individually for $14.99 on the PA online store.
PAX Aus 2017 Logo
Set: Aus 2017 Core
Available at Pax Aus 2017.
World of Warships
Set: Prime Partners 2015
The first-ever Wargaming PAX pin will be available to the first 1,000 people to play World of Warships each day at the Wargaming Booth #232. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Prime 2015 Logo
Set: Prime Core 2015
Available for purchase for $30 at the Pax Prime 2015 merch booth.
Kristin Lindsay
Set: Staff 2013
Find Kristen at PAX or other public PA events - trade any pin with her to receive her pin. Pin design by Tavis Maiden.
Rupee
Set: Zelda 2017
First available at the Merch booth at PAX East 2017, later available at the PA Online store.
Jump Luigi
Set: Misc 2016
Available by purchasing from the PA online store, Winter 2016. Not technically part of the World 1-1 set, but of the same ilk.
Splatter Frank
Set: Armadeaddon 2015
Part of the Armadeaddon 2015 set released in Oct 2015 on the PA Store as a series of blind boxes. Given the relative difficulty of outright purchasing these pins, the whole set is likely to be highly tradable. Splatter Frank had a 1/10 drop frequency, making it somewhat uncommon in the set.
Hammer Mario
Set: Super Mario Bros. 3
From the SMB3 blind box set available on the PA Online store in 2017/2018.
Bad Penny
Set: Unplugged 2018 Partners
Play a demo of KeyForge at the Fantasy Flight Games booth #2801 to receive the pin.
Brian Sunter
Set: Staff 2014
Part of the 2014 Staff Pins set, revealed at Pax Prime 2014. Get this by trading with Brian anytime.
Fire Flower
Set: World 1-2 Set
Available from the PA Online store starting in Summer 2017.
PAX South 2017
Set: South Core 2017
Available at both PAX Merch Booths, PAX South 2017. These pins were taken from the PAX South program cover, (a theme throughout the 2017 PAX core sets).
State of Decay 1
Set: South Partners 2015
Get this pin for free (for playing a game demo) at the Undead Labs booth.
Sully
Set: Misc 2016
Available for purchase from the US Playstation Gear store for $12. 1,000 were printed, but expect these to be somewhat rare as they arent promoted elsewhere.
Troop Leader Tycho
Set: Halloween 2015
Available for sale at the PA Online store.
Angus
Set: South Partners 2019
Available for purchase at the Finji booth #10609.
Pit People 2
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at The Behemoth Booth #3004
Medius the Cannibal
Set: Aus Partners 2015
Available at the Tin Man Games Booth in PAX Rising.
Bard Rock
Set: East Partners 2014
For sale at Scott Kurtzs booth, PAX East 2014.
Tycho Bar
Set: Summer Treats
Available from the PA Online store starting in Summer 2017.
Orchid
Set: Killer Instinct
The first PinUltimate set, these pins are available by completing certain online tasks/challenges in Killer Instinct on the Xbox One, and subsequently sold individually for $14.99 on the PA online store.
Cthulhu Swim
Set: West Partners 2016
Available at Kris Straub table in Bandland.
Octorok
Set: Zelda 2017
First available at the Merch booth at PAX East 2017, later available at the PA Online store.
Bullet Bill
Set: Super Mario Odyssey Capture Set 2018
First available for purchase online in Nov 2018.
Muffins
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at the LoadingReadyRun table in Bandland. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
8 Bit Upside Down Gabe
Set: Aus 2018 Core
Available at both PAX Merch Booths which are located in the Exhibition Centre.
Prime 2015 Gabe
Set: Prime Core 2015
Available for purchase for $30 at the Pax Prime 2015 merch booth.
Headcrab
Set: South Partners 2016
Originally available from We Love Fine at PAX South 2016. This pin was not listed on PAs pin quest post, and so may have flown under the radar for a lot of folks. Subsequently available at PAX East 2016, at the We Love Fine booth #5212.
Deadstream
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
WASD
Set: Misc 2018
Available for purchase online in Nov 2018.
Mario Kart Mario
Set: Mario Kart Blind Box 2018
This is part of the Mario Kart Racer Blind Box set. Random boxes of 2 pins each were sold online for $20 a box or $220 for a case of 12. The published odds of getting this pin are 1/10.
Omin Dran
Set: Acquisitions Inc.
Available for sale at the online PA Store for a limited but lengthy time in 2013/2014. No longer available, but readily found through trading.
Kill Doctor Lucky
Set: Unplugged 2018 Partners
Available for purchase at the Cheapass Games booth #2458 or discounted with demo.
Ursine Adventures
Set: Staff 2016
Part of the 2016 Staff pins set. First revealed at East 2016. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Dabe. From the PA strip titled Ursine Adventures.
Dabe Alan
Set: Staff 2015
Part of the 2015 Staff Pins set, revealed at East 2015. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Dabe. Pin design by Katie Rice.
VR Gabe
Set: West Core 2016
Available for purchase from the PAX West (does Prime = West now? Ugh..) merch booth.
Mecha FF
Set: South Core 2016
Available for purchase from the merch booth at PAX South 2016.
Rage Tycho
Set: Staff 2016
Part of the 2016 Staff pins set. First revealed at East 2016. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Tycho.
Mike Fehlauer
Set: Staff 2014
Part of the 2014 Staff Pins set, revealed at Pax Prime 2014. Get this by trading with Feh anytime.
Clicker
Set: Misc
Available for sale from Naughty Dogs online store. Part of Naughty Dogs 30th Anniversary celebration.
Torg
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for purchase at the LoadingReadyRun table in Bandland.
Fulgore
Set: Killer Instinct
The first PinUltimate set, these pins are available by completing certain online tasks/challenges in Killer Instinct on the Xbox One, and subsequently sold individually for $14.99 on the PA online store.
Gang Beasts
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for purchase at the Double Fine booth #106.
8 Bit Gabe
Set: PAX South 2018
Available at PAX South 2018.
Rosie Holiday
Set: Christmas 2017
Available online at the Penny Arcade Store.
Doorbot
Set: West Partners 2018
Available for purchase or free with purchase of Clank! or Clank! In! Space! at the Dire Wolf booth #7405.
PAX East 2015 Logo
Set: East Core 2015
Part of the core 2015 East set, available for purchase from the merch booth.
Der Dorbelgorbel
Set: Staff 2016
Part of the 2016 Staff pins set. First revealed at East 2016. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Kiko. From the PA strip titled Der Dorbelgorbel.
Super Star
Set: Misc 2017
Available for purchase, for the first time, at both PAX West 2017 Merch Booths. Available on the Penny Arcade Store on September 13th, 2017.
He/Him
Set: PAX Pronoun Set
First available for purchase at PAX East 2018. Designed by Gavin Greco.
Iota
Set: East Partners 2014
Available at the Playstation booth, PAX East 2014. Tearaway was also available at the PS booth at Prime 2014, making this pin a bit more common.
Bit Brigade
Set: West Partners 2018
Available for purchase at the Bit Brigade table in Bandland.
8 Bit Thornwatch Woldsen
Set: Unplugged 2018 Core
Available at the Official PAX Merch Booths located in the Expo Hall and the Level 2 lobby.
Jake
Set: Prime Partners 2014
Part of the We Love Fine pin set at PAX Prime 2014.
Dave Coffman
Set: Staff 2014
Part of the 2014 Staff Pins set, revealed at Pax Prime 2014. Get this by trading with Dave anytime.
Rogue Singularity
Set: Aus Partners 2016
Available for $20 AUD each at the Considerable Content Stand 18. Includes Steam Early Access for Rogue Singularity.
Co-Optional Podcast
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at the Maker Booth #3835. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Forts Eagle Empire Insignia
Set: Aus 2017 Partners
Available at Pax Aus 2017.
Sabrewulf
Set: Killer Instinct
The first PinUltimate set, these pins are available by completing certain online tasks/challenges in Killer Instinct on the Xbox One, and subsequently sold individually for $14.99 on the PA online store.
FNAF Nightmare Cupcake
Set: East Partners 2017
Available at the ThinkGeek Booth #15090.
Screencheat Logo
Set: Aus Partners 2015
Available at the Samurai Punk Booth in PAX Rising.
Ooooooooo
Set: PA Emote 2019
First available at the PAX South 2019 Merch booth, later made available on the online store.
Blood Rage FF
Set: Armadeaddon 2015
Part of the Armadeaddon 2015 set released in Oct 2015 on the PA Store as a series of blind boxes. Given the relative difficulty of outright purchasing these pins, the whole set is likely to be highly tradable. Blood Rage FF had a 1/8 drop frequency, the most common in the set.
Egg Josh
Set: Staff 2017
Trade with Josh. First available at PAX East 2017.
Gabe Marley
Set: Christmas 2014
For sale online at the PA Shop for a limitied time in Winter 2014. Characters in this set are inspired by Charles Dickens Christmas Carol.
Hand of Fate 1
Set: Aus 2017 Partners
Available at Pax Aus 2017.
Flumph
Set: Unplugged 2018 Partners
Available for purchase at the D&D Adventurers League area in room #113. Anyone wearing either last year’s pin or this years pin while playing gets a special surprise for their characters!
Gingerbread Gabe
Set: Christmas 2015
Part of the Christmas 2015 set, for sale on the online PA store.
Snow Level Tycho
Set: PAX Unplugged 2017
Available at PAX Unplugged.
Levin Sadsad
Set: Staff 2013
Find Levin at PAX or other public PA events - trade any pin with him to receive his pin. Levin left PA in 2014, but promises to still hang around pin-trading at PA events. Starting with PAX Prime 2014, this staff set was retired and replaced with the symbols staff set. Since Levin left PA, before that time, this is his only staff pin. Pin design by Tavis Maiden.
YIIK Vella
Set: South Partners 2019
Come to our booth #10452 and complete the demo of YIIK in order to receive one complimentary Vella pin!
Surprise Attack Ninja
Set: South Partners 2016
Available at the Surprise Attack Games Booth #11102 at PAX South 2016.
2015 PAX Aus Logo
Set: Aus Core 2015
Part of the Pax Aus 2015 core set. Only available from the merch booth at Pax Aus 2015.
Bwoomp
Set: PA Emote 2019
First available at the PAX South 2019 Merch booth, later made available on the online store.
A Whimsical God
Set: Staff 2016
Part of the 2016 Staff pins set. First revealed at East 2016. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Mike (Feh). From the PA strip titled A Whimsical God.
Ice Cream Erick
Set: Staff 2017
Trade with Erick. First available at PAX East 2017.
Scuba Gabe
Set: Aus Core 2015
Part of the Pax Aus 2015 core set. Only available from the merch booth at Pax Aus 2015.
Merch 2.0
Set: Merch
Available at any PAX merch booth in 2014 when spending more than $99. Replaced in 2015 by Merch 3.0
Pizza Gavin
Set: Staff 2017
Trade with Gavin. First available at PAX East 2017.
Mario Kart Yoshi
Set: Mario Kart Blind Box 2018
This is part of the Mario Kart Racer Blind Box set. Random boxes of 2 pins each were sold online for $20 a box or $220 for a case of 12. The published odds of getting this pin are 3/40.
Josh Price
Set: Staff 2013
Find Josh at PAX or other public PA events - trade any pin with him to receive his pin. Starting with PAX Prime 2014, this staff set was retired and replaced with the symbols staff set. Pin design by Tavis Maiden.
Pit People Spidaur
Set: East Partners 2017
Available at The Behemoth Booth #14000 & #14005.
Mike Fehlauer
Set: Staff 2015
Part of the 2015 Staff Pins set, revealed at East 2015. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Mike. Pin design by Katie Rice.
Burning Wheel
Set: PAX Unplugged 2017
Available at PAX Unplugged.
Knights and Bikes
Set: West Partners 2018
Available for purchase at the Double Fine Productions booth #106.
Coin
Set: World 1-2 Set
Available from the PA Online store starting in Summer 2017.
Enfu 2
Set: Enfu 2015
Part of the 2015 Enfu set, should be available for purchase from the online PA store in November.
Jeff Kalles
Set: Staff 2015
Part of the 2015 Staff Pins set, revealed at East 2015. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Jeff. Pin design by Katie Rice.
PAX West 2018 Logo
Set: West Core 2018
Available at the PAX Merch Booths (West 2018) located in the WSCC Atrium Lobby and the Sheraton Lobby.
Munchkin: Spyke
Set: PAX Unplugged 2017
Available at PAX Unplugged.
Shu
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
Gabe Sketch 1
Set: Sketch Set
First available at SDCC 2014, and subsequently sold online at the PA Store.
Due Process
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
Rainbow 6
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Visit the Rainbow Six Booth #632 and participate in Siege Games (for a chance to win a trip to Los Angeles for Siege Day), take a picture in front of the Rainbow Six backdrop and share it with their friends on social media using the #RainbowSix. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
TF2 Soldier
Set: East Partners 2015
For purchase at the Valve Store (booth 9212)
Lookouts 02
Set: Lookouts
For sale at the online PA Store. These pins are the cheapest you can buy on a per-pin basis, and so are often bought in bulk as trade fodder with PA Staff for better pins.
Gabe Sketch 2
Set: Sketch Set
First available at SDCC 2014, and subsequently sold online at the PA Store.
Twisp
Set: Twisp & Catsby
Available for sale at the online PA Store.
Core 2 FF
Set: Core 2.0
The original Core pin set was available online for 3 years, and served as the foundational building blocks for Pinny Arcade. That set was retired in summer 2015 and replaced with Core 2.0. This set is available at the online PA store, and these pins will likely become quite common.
Tycho Wreath
Set: Christmas 2016
Available by purchasing from the PA online store, Winter 2016.
Mario Kart Toad
Set: Mario Kart Blind Box 2018
This is part of the Mario Kart Racer Blind Box set. Random boxes of 2 pins each were sold online for $20 a box or $220 for a case of 12. The published odds of getting this pin are 1/10.
Bride Anne
Set: Halloween 2014
For sale online at the PA Shop for a limitied time in Fall 2014.
Nacho Feh
Set: Staff 2017
Trade with Mike (Feh). First available at PAX East 2017.
Ashen
Set: Aus 2017 Partners
Available at Pax Aus 2017.
Riptor
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Stop by the Astro Gaming Booth #3217 and challenge members of the Killer Instinct production team to try and win a Riptor pin. Pin name and image to be updated as more info is released.
Mixer Hype
Set: West Partners 2017
At Booth #425: Attendees must walk up to one of 2 stations in our booth where they can sign up or verify that they have a Mixer Account registered. Once verified, they will be handed a pin.
Question Block
Set: World 1-1 Set
Available at the PA Online Store Fall/Winter 2016.
It Not Perfect System
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for purchase at the LoadingReadyRun table in Bandland.
Ironic Yorick
Set: Aus Partners 2016
Available for $20 AUD each at the Tin Man Games Stand 33. They will have some previous pins available, and can buy two pins for $30.
Albert
Set: Aus Partners 2016
Available for $20 AUD each at the Surprise Attack Games Stand PR10.
Skeleton FF
Set: Halloween 2016
Available at the PA Online Store Fall 2016
Gavin Greco
Set: Staff 2015
Part of the 2015 Staff Pins set, revealed at East 2015. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Gavin. Pin design by Katie Rice.
Waffle Travis
Set: Staff 2017
Trade with Travis. First available at PAX East 2017.
Castle
Set: Unplugged 2018 Partners
Available for purchase at the Stronghold Games booth #2915.
Gibb
Set: South Partners 2019
Available for purchase at the LoadingReadyRun table in Bandland.
Ben Kuchera
Set: Staff 2013
Originally an in-person staff trade at PA events, Ben left PA in 2013, and so his pin is hard to come by these days. Most likely found by trading with other collectors, or hunting down spares from remaining PA staff.
Tiny Div
Set: Christmas 2014
For sale online at the PA Shop for a limitied time in Winter 2014. Characters in this set are inspired by Charles Dickens Christmas Carol.
Masquerada: Oil
Set: PAX South 2018
Available at PAX South 2018.
Krog
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for purchase at the LoadingReadyRun table in Bandland.
Prime 2015 Tycho
Set: Prime Core 2015
Available for purchase for $30 at the Pax Prime 2015 merch booth.
American Dream
Set: East Partners 2017
Available at the Samurai Punk Booth #15078.
Naughty Dog 30
Set: Misc
This pin debuted at a special art show celebrating the 30th anniversary of Naughty Dog studios, in Alhambra, CA on Sept 27 2014. A limited number of pins was available (~30) and sold out quickly. Naughty Dog has hinted that the pin will be more widely available in the future.
Dabe Alan
Set: Staff 2014
Part of the 2014 Staff Pins set, revealed at Pax Prime 2014. Get this by trading with Dabe anytime.
Brian Sunter
Set: Staff 2015
Part of the 2015 Staff Pins set, revealed at East 2015. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Brian. Pin design by Katie Rice.
Annie
Set: West Partners 2017
Available at the Riot Games room (6th Floor) #614, #613.
Oksana
Set: Staff 2018
Available by trading in-person with Kiko or Mike in 2018. Design by Nick Trujillo.
Kobolds Ate My Baby 20th
Set: Unplugged 2018 Partners
Available for purchase at the 9th Level Games booth #3048.
Orcane Pinny
Set: West Partners 2018
Available for purchase with a free copy of Rivals of Aether for Steam at the Dan Fornace booth #120.
Wendy O. Koopa
Set: Super Mario Bros. 3
From the SMB3 blind box set available on the PA Online store in 2017/2018.
Skull Fart
Set: Prime Partners 2013
For sale at Scott Kurtzs booth.
PAX South 2018 Logo
Set: PAX South 2018
Available at PAX South 2018.
Duelyst Lyonar
Set: West Partners 2016
Available at the Counterplay Games Booth #6817.
Pit People Cyclops
Set: East Partners 2017
Available at The Behemoth Booth #14000 & #14005.
DD2 Canon Tower
Set: South Partners 2015
Available on a limited basis from the Trendy Entertainment booth. To get the pin you need to purchase Dungeon Defenders 2.
8 Bit Thornwatch Sage
Set: Unplugged 2018 Core
Available at the Official PAX Merch Booths located in the Expo Hall and the Level 2 lobby.
Mr. Period
Set: Staff 2018
Available by trading in-person with Lidija or Travis in 2018. Design by Nick Trujillo.
Merch 4.0
Set: Merch Exclusive 2016
Available for free at PAX Merch booths when purchasing $100 or more throughout 2016.
Sophia Hex
Set: East Partners 2015
Available from The Behemoth booth (5020). Pay $10 at their booth to receive (at random) one of their five pins. By asking really nicely, you may be able to trade them for a specific pin you still need.
Moon
Set: Twisp & Catsby
Available for sale at the online PA Store.
The Gardens Between Arina
Set: East Partners 2017
Available at the Voxel Agents Booth #16086.
Witchalok
Set: Staff 2018
Available by trading in-person with Dabe or Elyssa in 2018. Design by Nick Trujillo.
Herk
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for purchase at the LoadingReadyRun table in Bandland.
Firecat
Set: Killer Instinct
The first PinUltimate set, these pins are available by completing certain online tasks/challenges in Killer Instinct on the Xbox One, and subsequently sold individually for $14.99 on the PA online store.
Grace
Set: Staff 2018
Available by trading in-person with Kristin in 2018. Design by Nick Trujillo.
Jamie Dillion
Set: Staff 2013
Find Jamie at PAX or other public PA events - trade any pin with her to receive her pin. Starting with PAX Prime 2014, this staff set was retired and replaced with the symbols staff set. Pin design by Tavis Maiden.
Harmonix RB4
Set: East Partners 2015
Harmonix pin to celebrate the announcement of Rock Band 4. Get the pin at the Harmonix booth!
Bullet Hero
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for purchase at the Devolver booth #2201.
Lookouts Leader
Set: Lookouts
For sale at the online PA Store. These pins are the cheapest you can buy on a per-pin basis, and so are often bought in bulk as trade fodder with PA Staff for better pins.
Kristin Lindsay
Set: Staff 2014
Part of the 2014 Staff Pins set, revealed at Pax Prime 2014. Get this by trading with Kristin anytime.
Dragoon Wrench
Set: PAX Unplugged 2017
Available at PAX Unplugged.
TF2 Pyro
Set: East Partners 2015
For purchase at the Valve Store (booth 9212)
Codex Parentes
Set: Staff 2016
Part of the 2016 Staff pins set. First revealed at East 2016. Get this pin by trading any other pin with David. From the PA strip titled Codex Parentes.
Lil Ronin
Set: Aus 2018 Partners
Available for purchase at the Green Ronin booth TT664.
Pillars of Eternity II - Tekehu
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
Descenders Helmet
Set: South Partners 2019
Available for purchase at the No More Robots booth #10611.
Lookouts 04
Set: Lookouts
For sale at the online PA Store. These pins are the cheapest you can buy on a per-pin basis, and so are often bought in bulk as trade fodder with PA Staff for better pins.
Sexy Nurse Gabe
Set: Halloween 2014
For sale online at the PA Shop for a limitied time in Fall 2014.
Koopa Troopa
Set: World 1-1 Set
Available at the PA Online Store Fall/Winter 2016.
Pit People 3
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at The Behemoth Booth #3004
Blind (The Warden)
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
Sunset Overdrive
Set: Prime Partners 2014
Susent Overdrive was originally available at the Microsoft Studios boothat PAX Prime 2014, and also available at PAX Aus 2014.
Granok
Set: Prime Partners 2013
Avaialble at partner booths at Pax Prime 2013.
Octo Face
Set: East Partners 2015
Available from The Behemoth booth (5020). Pay $10 at their booth to receive (at random) one of their five pins. By asking really nicely, you may be able to trade them for a specific pin you still need.
Back Off Barbarian
Set: East Partners 2017
Available at The Behemoth Booth #14000 & #14005.
Yosef Hex
Set: East Partners 2015
Available from The Behemoth booth (5020). Pay $10 at their booth to receive (at random) one of their five pins. By asking really nicely, you may be able to trade them for a specific pin you still need.
Flower Cup
Set: Mario Kart Classic Cups 2018
Available for purchase online in Nov 2018.
Intern Morgan
Set: Aquisitions Incorporated
Available by purchasing the Aquisitions Inc blind box set from the PA online store. Winter 2016.
Lookouts 01
Set: Lookouts
For sale at the online PA Store. These pins are the cheapest you can buy on a per-pin basis, and so are often bought in bulk as trade fodder with PA Staff for better pins.
Jim Darkmagic
Set: Aquisitions Incorporated
Available by purchasing the Aquisitions Inc blind box set from the PA online store. Winter 2016.
The Ungift
Set: Staff 2016
Part of the 2016 Staff pins set. First revealed at East 2016. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Brian. From the PA strip titled The Ungift.
Them There End Times
Set: Staff 2016
Part of the 2016 Staff pins set. First revealed at East 2016. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Erick. From the PA strip titled Them There End Times.
Spinal Shield
Set: Killer Instinct
The first PinUltimate set, these pins are available by completing certain online tasks/challenges in Killer Instinct on the Xbox One, and subsequently sold individually for $14.99 on the PA online store.
MC Frontalot
Set: East Partners 2014
For sale at MC Frontalots booth, PAX East 2014.
Donaar Holiday
Set: Christmas 2017
Available online at the Penny Arcade Store.
Trap Roomba Binwin
Set: Aquisitions Incorporated
Available by purchasing the Aquisitions Inc blind box set from the PA online store. Winter 2016.
Erick Blandin
Set: Staff 2015
Part of the 2015 Staff Pins set, revealed at East 2015. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Erick. Pin design by Katie Rice.
PAX Aus 2016 Logo
Set: Aus Core 2016
Available at the Merch booth at PAX Aus 2016
Troll Revere
Set: East Partners 2016
Available at the Toonhound Booth #2042.
Pit People 4
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at The Behemoth Booth #3004
Platform FF
Set: South Core 2017
Available at both PAX Merch Booths, PAX South 2017. These pins were taken from the PAX South program cover, (a theme throughout the 2017 PAX core sets).
Esther
Set: Staff 2018
Available by trading in-person with Laura or Dora in 2018. Design by Nick Trujillo.
Framed 2
Set: Aus 2017 Partners
Available at Pax Aus 2017.
H1Z1 King of the Hill
Set: West Partners 2016
Head to the H1Z1: King of the Kill Box of Destiny (4th Floor, S2 Atrium Lobby), strike a winners stance on the podium and post your photo to Twitter or Instagram. Make sure to include the hashtag #TakeYourShot and tag @H1Z1KotK. Then, be one of the first 500 participants to come to the H1Z1: King of the Kill Twitch Partner Lounge each day (Booth #1909) to play a match and show us your post to claim your official H1Z1: King of the Kill pin
Cyberdemon
Set: East Partners 2016
Available at the Bethesda booth #8021.
Vindaloo Patrick
Set: Staff 2017
Trade with Patrick. First available at PAX East 2017.
Walnut Holiday
Set: Christmas 2017
Available online at the Penny Arcade Store.
Taco Kiko
Set: Staff 2017
Trade with Kiko. First available at PAX East 2017.
Kristin Lindsay
Set: Staff 2015
Part of the 2015 Staff Pins set, revealed at East 2015. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Kristen. Pin design by Katie Rice.
Im A Table Titan
Set: Christmas 2016
You know, Im really not sure where to get this one...
Fruits of a Feather
Set: Aus Partners 2016
Available for $20 AUD each at the Samurai Punk Stand 23. Buy both Mallow Drops and Samurai Punk pins for $30.
Pit People 1
Set: Prime Partners 2015
Available at The Behemoth Booth #3004
Construct
Set: West Partners 2016
Available at Perfect World Booth #133.
Hand of Fate 2
Set: Aus 2017 Partners
Available at Pax Aus 2017.
Intern Aeofel
Set: Aquisitions Incorporated
Available by purchasing the Aquisitions Inc blind box set from the PA online store. Winter 2016.
Larry Koopa
Set: Super Mario Bros. 3
From the SMB3 blind box set available on the PA Online store in 2017/2018.
Enfu Tiger
Set: East Partners 2017
Available at both PAX Merch Booths.
Dragon Friends
Set: Aus 2018 Partners
Available for purchase at the Good Games RPG booth TT130.
Mario Kart Waluigi
Set: Mario Kart Blind Box 2018
This is part of the Mario Kart Racer Blind Box set. Random boxes of 2 pins each were sold online for $20 a box or $220 for a case of 12. The published odds of getting this pin are 3/40.
Balloon Man
Set: Twisp & Catsby
Available for sale at the online PA Store.
Merch 5.0
Set: Misc 2017
Available at both PAX Merch booths, starting at PAX East 2017.
Aftercharge
Set: West Partners 2018
Available for purchase at the Chainsawesome Games booth #740.
Love (Facebook)
Set: West Partners 2018
Available with tokens that can be earned by participating in several activities at the Facebook booth #803.
Merch 5.0
Set: Merch Exclusive 2017
First available at both PAX West 2017 Merch booths.
Wattam
Set: PAX South 2018
Available at PAX South 2018.
Shadow Jago
Set: Killer Instinct
The first PinUltimate set, these pins are available by completing certain online tasks/challenges in Killer Instinct on the Xbox One, and subsequently sold individually for $14.99 on the PA online store.
Age of Empires
Set: Prime Partners 2014
The Age of Empires pin was available at the Microsoft Studios boothat PAX Prime 2014.
CEO Omin
Set: Aquisitions Incorporated
Available by purchasing the Aquisitions Inc blind box set from the PA online store. Winter 2016.
Gloomweaver
Set: East Partners 2017
Available at The Greater Than Games Booth #11087.
Rage Gabe
Set: Staff 2016
Part of the 2016 Staff pins set. First revealed at East 2016. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Gabe.
Josh Price
Set: Staff 2015
Part of the 2015 Staff Pins set, revealed at East 2015. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Josh. Pin design by Katie Rice.
Eternal Jekk
Set: East Partners 2017
Available at the Dire Wolf Digital Booth #18114.
PAX East 2018 Logo
Set: East 2018 Core
Part of the East Core 2018 set. Available for purchase at the Merch booth.
Merch 3.0
Set: Merch Exclusive 2015
Available from the merch booth as an add-on when spending more than $99. Merch 3.0 debuted at PAX East 2015.
The Banner Saga 3 - Juno
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
FF Payload
Set: East Core 2017
Available at both Merch booths.
Pixel
Set: PAX South 2018
Available at PAX South 2018.
Draken
Set: Prime Partners 2013
Avaialble at partner booths at Pax Prime 2013.
Splatter Gabe
Set: Armadeaddon 2015
Part of the Armadeaddon 2015 set released in Oct 2015 on the PA Store as a series of blind boxes. Given the relative difficulty of outright purchasing these pins, the whole set is likely to be highly tradable. Splatter Gabe had a 1/8 drop frequency, the most common in the set.
Drowning Tycho
Set: West Core 2017
Available for purchase from the PAX West merch booth.
Red Para Goomba
Set: Super Mario Bros. 3
From the SMB3 blind box set available on the PA Online store in 2017/2018.
YIIK Alex
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
Jamie Dillion
Set: Staff 2015
Part of the 2015 Staff Pins set, revealed at East 2015. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Jamie. Pin design by Katie Rice.
Core 2 Tycho
Set: Core 2.0
The original Core pin set was available online for 3 years, and served as the foundational building blocks for Pinny Arcade. That set was retired in summer 2015 and replaced with Core 2.0. This set is available at the online PA store, and these pins will likely become quite common.
Rainbow Cookie Lidija
Set: Staff 2017
Trade with Lidija. First available at PAX East 2017.
Zombie Dice
Set: PAX Unplugged 2017
Available at PAX Unplugged.
Force Multiplier
Set: Staff 2016
Part of the 2016 Staff pins set. First revealed at East 2016. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Erik. From the PA strip titled Force Multiplier.
Gabe Wreath
Set: Christmas 2016
Available by purchasing from the PA online store, Winter 2016.
Iron Twisp
Set: South Core 2016
Available for purchase from the merch booth at PAX South 2016.
Subtle Boom
Set: Aus 2018 Partners
Available at the Subtle Boom booth PR46 with the completion of a single activity from several options including a game demo, design an in-game collectible skin, or achieving a top score of an endless level. The pin will also be available for purchase.
Glacius
Set: Killer Instinct
The first PinUltimate set, these pins are available by completing certain online tasks/challenges in Killer Instinct on the Xbox One, and subsequently sold individually for $14.99 on the PA online store.
Nut So Fast
Set: Unplugged 2018 Partners
Available for purchase at the Smirk & Dagger Games booth #3049.
Human Era Machine
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
Dave Coffman
Set: Staff 2015
Part of the 2015 Staff Pins set, revealed at East 2015. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Dave. Pin design by Katie Rice.
Intern Viari
Set: Aquisitions Incorporated
Available by purchasing the Aquisitions Inc blind box set from the PA online store. Winter 2016.
TBS 2 Bolverk
Set: East Partners 2016
Available at the Versus Evil booth #10081.
Rhythm Bex
Set: East Core 2016
Part of the core 2016 East set, only available for purchase from the merch booth.
8-Bit Omin Dran
Set: East 2018 Core
Part of the East Core 2018 set. Available for purchase at the Merch booth.
Elf Tycho
Set: Christmas 2013
Available for sale at the online PA Store for a limited but lengthy time in 2013/2014. No longer available, but readily found through trading.
Savage New Brutals
Set: Staff 2016
Part of the 2016 Staff pins set. First revealed at East 2016. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Jeff. From the PA strip titled Savage New Brutals.
Champions of Midgard
Set: Unplugged 2018 Partners
Available for purchase at the Grey Fox Games booth #1913.
Dave Coffman
Set: Staff 2013
Find Dave at PAX or other public PA events - trade any pin with him to receive his pin. Starting with PAX Prime 2014, this staff set was retired and replaced with the symbols staff set. Pin design by Tavis Maiden.
Splatter Galahad
Set: Armadeaddon
Part of the Armadeaddon 2015 set released in Oct 2015 on the PA Store as a series of blind boxes. Given the relative difficulty of outright purchasing these pins, the whole set is likely to be highly tradable. Splatter Galahad had a 1/10 drop frequency, making it somewhat uncommon in the set.
Samurai Punk
Set: West Partners 2016
Available for $15 at the Samurai Punk Booth #6214.
Gabe
Set: Core Online Set 2013
Part of the original core pin pack, released in 2012 and retired in summer 2015. Likely to remain very common for quite some time.
Josh Price
Set: Staff 2014
Part of the 2014 Staff Pins set, revealed at Pax Prime 2014. Get this by trading with Josh anytime.
Mario Kart Wario
Set: Mario Kart Blind Box 2018
This is part of the Mario Kart Racer Blind Box set. Random boxes of 2 pins each were sold online for $20 a box or $220 for a case of 12. The published odds of getting this pin are 3/40.
Guitar Viari
Set: East Partners 2017
Available at the Toonhound Booth #10009.
Wow (Facebook)
Set: West Partners 2018
The face you make when you realize how Facebook treats your privacy. Available with tokens that can be earned by participating in several activities at the Facebook booth #803.
The Little Hashshashin
Set: Staff 2016
Part of the 2016 Staff pins set. First revealed at East 2016. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Kristen. From the PA strip titled The Little Hashshashin.
Kissin Gabe
Set: Staff 2018
Available by trading in-person with Gabe (Mike) in 2018.
Core 2 Div
Set: Core 2.0
The original Core pin set was available online for 3 years, and served as the foundational building blocks for Pinny Arcade. That set was retired in summer 2015 and replaced with Core 2.0. This set is available at the online PA store, and these pins will likely become quite common.
Lawbreakers Faust
Set: East Partners 2017
Available at the Nexon Booth #13055. Get a pin by play testing LawBreakers. Will be given out at Boss Key Panel - Friday 9pm, Bumblebee Theatre. LawBreakers Staff will also trade for the pin.
Scuba Tycho
Set: Aus Core 2015
Part of the Pax Aus 2015 core set. Only available from the merch booth at Pax Aus 2015.
Bandit Queen
Set: South Partners 2017
Available for $15 each at the Dire Wolf Digital Booth #10641. Will also be given away to players who win demo games throughout the weekend.
Tycho Sketch 2
Set: Sketch Set
First available at SDCC 2014, and subsequently sold online at the PA Store.
Chloe
Set: Misc
Available for sale from the US Playstation online store.
The Dark Room
Set: Aus 2018 Partners
Available for purchase at the The Dark Room Booth Stand 55.
8 Bit Thornwatch Warden
Set: Unplugged 2018 Core
Available at the Official PAX Merch Booths located in the Expo Hall and the Level 2 lobby.
Falcon
Set: South Partners 2017
Available for $15 each at the tinyBuildGAMES Booth #10669.
Duelyst Songhai Crest
Set: West Partners 2016
Available at the Counterplay Games Booth #6817.
Orange IMP
Set: West Partners 2018
Available for purchase at the Sony Interactive Entertainment booth #217.
Enfu Gorilla
Set: East Partners 2017
Available at both PAX Merch Booths.
Kiko Villasenor
Set: Staff 2015
Part of the 2015 Staff Pins set, revealed at East 2015. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Kiko. Pin design by Katie Rice.
The Maw
Set: Staff 2016
Part of the 2016 Staff pins set. First revealed at East 2016. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Josh. From the PA strip titled The Maw.
Figs n Co
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
No Turkey
Set: PA Emote 2019
First available at the PAX South 2019 Merch booth, later made available on the online store.
Death Squared Red
Set: Aus Partners 2015
Available at the SMG Studio Booth in PAX Rising.
Black Light Cerberus
Set: East Partners 2018
Available from booth partners at PAX East 2018.
Dark Brotherhood
Set: West Partners 2016
Available for $10 each at the PAX West 2016 at the Bethesda Booth #1102, 1303.
PAX South 2016 Logo
Set: South Core 2016
Available for purchase from the merch booth at PAX South 2016.
Dr. Raven Darktalon Blood
Set: Staff 2018
Available by trading in-person with Dave or Patrick in 2018. Design by Nick Trujillo.
Lawful Naughty
Set: Misc 2018
Available for purchase online in Nov 2018.
Molotov
Set: West Partners 2017
Available for purchase at the New Blood Interactive booth #7218 - Play the demo for a pin discount.
Nerdcore Hip Hop
Set: PAX South 2018
Available at PAX South 2018.
Death Squared Blue
Set: Aus Partners 2015
Available at the SMG Studio Booth in PAX Rising.
GtG Matriarch
Set: South Partners 2016
Originaly available at PAX South 2016 ath the Greater Than Games booth in the Tabletop area. Also available at PAX East 2016 at the GtG booth #2180.
8 Bit Fruit Friend
Set: West Core 2018
Available at the PAX Merch Booths (West 2018) located in the WSCC Atrium Lobby and the Sheraton Lobby.
Drake
Set: Misc 2016
Available for purchase from the US Playstation Gear store for $12. 1,000 were printed, but expect these to be somewhat rare as they arent promoted elsewhere.
Mario Kart Luigi
Set: Mario Kart Blind Box 2018
This is part of the Mario Kart Racer Blind Box set. Random boxes of 2 pins each were sold online for $20 a box or $220 for a case of 12. The published odds of getting this pin are 1/10.
Binwin Bronzebottom
Set: Acquisitions Inc.
Available for sale at the online PA Store for a limited but lengthy time in 2013/2014. No longer available, but readily found through trading.
Elena
Set: Misc 2016
Available for purchase from the US Playstation Gear store for $12. 1,000 were printed, but expect these to be somewhat rare as they arent promoted elsewhere.
Viking
Set: Prime Partners 2013
Available as a random participation prize at Behemoths booth at PAX Prime 2013. Getting one was easy, getting them all÷ not so much.
Think of the Children
Set: Aus 2017 Partners
Available at Pax Aus 2017.
Sadira
Set: Killer Instinct
The first PinUltimate set, these pins are available by completing certain online tasks/challenges in Killer Instinct on the Xbox One, and subsequently sold individually for $14.99 on the PA online store.
Dice Tower Guy
Set: PAX Unplugged 2017
Available at PAX Unplugged.
SoTM Baron Blade
Set: South Partners 2015
Available at the Greater Than Games booth.
Hello Neighbor
Set: East Partners 2017
Available at the tinyBuild Booth #13091.
Hexipal
Set: West Partners 2016
Available for $15 at the Double Fine Booth #106.
Cronos
Set: East Partners 2016
Available at the Nexon Booth #5116.
8 Bit Tycho
Set: PAX South 2018
Available at PAX South 2018.
Lookouts 03
Set: Lookouts
For sale at the online PA Store. These pins are the cheapest you can buy on a per-pin basis, and so are often bought in bulk as trade fodder with PA Staff for better pins.
Erik Bronnum
Set: Staff 2015
Part of the 2015 Staff Pins set, revealed at East 2015. Get this pin by trading any other pin with Erik. Pin design by Katie Rice.